News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Picking Co-Founders the Army Officer Way by jl2718 on Monday August 23, 2021 @01:11PM (#28278952)
No; this is just an elaboration on the author’s concept to give perspective on where it may be apt or lacking.
Re:Picking Co-Founders the Army Officer Way by travisjungroth on Monday August 23, 2021 @01:24PM (#28279149)
But what's your point?

The first word of your comment is "Imagine", then a bunch of description, then the last line is a summary of this imagined world. Ok, I imagined, now what?

You've taken a romanticized narrative of the military and then abstracted the terms so they could apply to startups. I can't engage with it as an analogy because it's an imaginary YC on top of an imaginary military. I can't engage with it as a position because you haven't made any claims outside the scope of this world you described.

Re:Picking Co-Founders the Army Officer Way by jl2718 on Monday August 23, 2021 @01:34PM (#28279288)
Ok well, frankly, I wrote this because I didn’t quite get the author’s point. To begin, military officers do not choose their team. I elaborated on the situation in order to highlight the situational differences between choosing startup cofounders and being put on a military team. I may have put this in an idealized form, but I think it is a bit closer to reality than most civilians would expect, at least in combat operations.

P.S. I should also mention that I have zero clue what YC is like in present or past form, so I couldn’t competently draw a direct comparison, instead inviting the reader to make their own.

Re:Picking Co-Founders the Army Officer Way by travisjungroth on Monday August 23, 2021 @02:26PM (#28279953)
With your other reply, I think I understand your point better. The situation of the military is super different from startups. Maybe also implied that means that we can't bring over giant lessons. I really agree with this.

I think the more different the context, the more specific the ideas you bring over should be (the trend seems to be the more different, the bigger the idea). So instead of trying to tell me the value of communication, I'd rather know in detail how one unit handles debriefings. Then I can maybe pick up some tips or try the whole thing.