Re:Razer bug lets you become a Windows 10 admin by plugging ...
by chris37879 on Monday August 23, 2021 @06:04PM
(#28282574)
There's a difference, though. Microsoft's Windows Update driver installer does not require launching executables, it never has in the past, it simply got the inf and supporting files and put them in the system's driver location. Now they're automatically running executable code that microsoft isn't verifying as an Administrator. Yes a malicious driver could be bad, but since drivers have a more finite api surface they should call, they can be audited / restricted with static analysis checks. launching a userspace app with admin privileges automatically is a bad idea.
Would you be ok with the AMD kernel driver launching a web browser as root on first boot? Or every boot?
Now, that user experience broadly sucks vs. plugging the same PCIe card into a Windows box and booting it up to get an automatically installed driver. But it's not subject to the same security problems either, which was my point.