Re:Picking Co-Founders the Army Officer Way
by JamesSwift on Monday August 23, 2021 @11:27AM
(#28277305)
I was never actually in the "armed" forces, but I did serve in the military, and I don't think the issue was lack of military force in Afghanistan. The problem was that we started off with overwhelming force, destroying civilian lives, and giving every opportunity for the taliban to generate anti-american sentiment in the process. It required a nuanced approach from day 1 and we didn't start that approach until day 300 (philosophically speaking). We needed to win the trust of the civilian population and we did nothing to secure that trust.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Picking Co-Founders the Army Officer Way
by ryanmarsh on Monday August 23, 2021 @11:33AM
(#28277410)
Exactly. This weird 21st century idea of military as gracious nation building conquerer is weird and we are not good at that.
Note that, conversely, force on force "wars" are won very quickly. We should have left Afghanistan in 2002.