News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My mouse driver is asking for a firewall exemption (2019) by detaro on Monday August 23, 2021 @09:18AM (#28275233)
I can just as well point at that thread and go "Isn't that the type of software HN keeps criticizing for being Electron?". Somehow people see discussions about A vs B and go "HN is totally always for A", despite the only reason you even see A so much is that it's hotly discussed every single time, with plenty people arguing B. And of course that shitty generalization is now top of the thread, instead of something discussing any substance specific to the submission.
Re:My mouse driver is asking for a firewall exemption (2019) by da_chicken on Monday August 23, 2021 @09:42AM (#28275548)
The perception is that the pro-Electron group is made up of all the people writing the software being discussed and therefore getting most of the benefits of their choice, while the anti-Electron group is made up of all the people criticizing it for having to put up with all the drawbacks for the end-user (and setting aside the fact that the software may not exist at all if not for those pro-Electron benefits).

However, since lots of software is still being written in Electron and... essentially none of the criticisms and drawbacks of doing so have been addressed, the anti-Electron group feels like they're being ignored. Because they are. So when they make posts about feeling ignored or complaining about having to repeat the same criticisms over and over without any improvement, that's because that's what's happening.

The anti-Electron people are not saying that nobody agrees with them. They're complaining that their arguments are clearly falling on deaf ears.

Re:My mouse driver is asking for a firewall exemption (2019) by acomjean on Monday August 23, 2021 @12:10PM (#28278065)
I suspect there is hope from the electron developers that somehow the platform will start getting less resource intensive.

App developers want their user to have a good experience (I'm guessing). But it isn't great with electron. But its fund one team or fund 3 ui teams (Windows, Mac, Linux) and hope testing gets them all in sync.

Unfortunately there isn't a great cross-platform solution (qt?) that makes everyone happy (or at least not furious).

Re:My mouse driver is asking for a firewall exemption (2019) by detaro on Monday August 23, 2021 @11:02AM (#28276847)
You also see non-devs saying Electron is fine, and if the complaints were considered is not something you can really tell. Few people deciding against Electron are going to loudly broadcast that "we were thinking about Electron", and if you consider it and decide it's worth it for you despite downsides, well, you are the "bad guy"(TM) anyways.
Re:My mouse driver is asking for a firewall exemption (2019) by Uehreka on Monday August 23, 2021 @04:11PM (#28281297)
Can you find pro-Electron comments? Sure, but if you browse any post about Electron you’ll see a lot of “Electron is a disrespect to your users!” comments, whose top reply is “Yes, and also…(more complaints)”, whose top reply is “Electron is the worst in a long line of…”

This kind of “reply-to-agree-and-pile-on” chain happens on HN a lot, but there are certain topics that really set it off, and Electron is definitely one. The commenters are commenting, the readers are upvoting, and what we end up with is an atmosphere where one side of the conversation is clearly getting more engagement.