edit: I'm actually curious what you think it is, I don't see one aside from "don't lose your soul" - but that's not an argument. That's advice. Who, or what, are they arguing against, and what is their counter-argument?
Help yourself to some rants here: http://www.subgenius.com/bigfist/classic/classicrants/classi...
It's "guns don't kill people, people kill people" all over again. You're a fool if you think something won't be corrupted by some, and equally foolish if you think everyone is corrupted. And if Wikipedia, Khan Academy, and 4chan aren't "web-2.0 social-empowerment", I'm not sure what is.
Maybe I'm just more irked than I should be at people who have rose-tinted glasses on (and they certainly do. to what degree is debatable, I'll leave it at that here). But I've encountered a number of people who seem not to, and they typically have incredible drive to mold the world into what they want, and rejoice in the changes they've lived through. They're almost universally fascinating, happy, energetic people. But maybe their glasses are in fact too blue(?)-tinted.
Still, I'd choose that over growing bitter and immobile.
From the article:
And therein lies the real problem of web 2.0 — whether it takes the form of SEO-driven “news” or crowd-sourced accommodation. To make money — real money — at this game you have to attract millions, or tens of millions, of users. And when you’re dealing with those kinds of numbers, it’s literally impossible not to treat your users as pieces of data. It’s ironic, but depressingly unsurprising, that web 2.0 is using faux socialization and democratization to create a world where everyone is reduced to a number on a spreadsheet.
[emphasis mine]
That's his argument. I don't agree with it but that doesn't make this a rant.
[Edit] Add a comment of my own
I knew a kid when he was knee-high who grew up to graduate at the top of his high school class. In his valedictory speech, full of chestnuts that were a bit too optimistic and ungrounded, he said the following:
"Work doesn't necessarily make you happy but it may give you the means to do the stuff that makes you happy."
I've always been struck by the simple wisdom of his statement. I think we can't always get everything from one area of life (job/career/startup). And that's fine.
Life is a balancing act, which implies it is dynamic. Sometimes we sway too far and fall and our friends catch us. And we get back on.
Paul mourns
" a not-too-distant past where technology entrepreneurs created things to make the world a better or more interesting place, not just because they wanted to make a billion dollars."
And this is in the past because:
"To make money — real money — at this game you have to attract millions, or tens of millions, of users. And when you’re dealing with those kinds of numbers, it’s literally impossible not to treat your users as pieces of data. It’s ironic, but depressingly unsurprising, that web 2.0 is using faux socialization and democratization to create a world where everyone is reduced to a number on a spreadsheet."
And finally:
"In the final analysis, a billion dollars isn’t actually all that cool. What’s cool is keeping your soul, whatever the financial cost."
Sometimes Paul has an interesting insight, but it's buried so deep in multiple layers of ranting that it's impossible to get there without a significant amount of willpower and spare time.
Please feel free to insert the "short letter" quote here...
EDIT: and please do feel free to add a comment why you are downvoting my comment.