I imagine you are chronically in-debt from your health bills, college loan, dead beat husband who lost his third job in a row and you still have to feed your two kids.
You go read some books for advice on being in a better financial shape, and they tell you “Just spend less money. If in the next weeks you still aren’t getting rich, spend even less money, and so on. It’s just simple math, spend less than you earn ! It’s hard but stay strong !”
I wonder how you’d feel about that advice.
But I stand to my comment that CICO works for weight loss.
It's not generally true, however, that people in financial disarray can get rich by just spending less. Our cost of living is a fundamental limit on how much we can save. But more than that, people can't get rich if they don't have a high income.
Besides, if the estimates are wrong and you are not losing weight just eat less calories in the next week and see what happens. This is a form of feedback control; this kind of control can lessen the impact of modelling errors.
If you stick to this plan, you're guaranteed to lose weight, 100% of time.
Detractors of CICO usually say that people don't have the willpower to stick to this plan indefinitely. This might be generally true for most people (I don't know). But alas, some people have enough willpower, and some have enough support, such as having their portions be prepared by someone else. For them, this strategy will always work.