Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by toolz on Saturday August 21, 2021 @11:28AM
(#28257756)
Typically people use raft for leader election which in turn can coordinate writes. I don't think the writes are being fsync'd in the raft logs here. At least I wouldn't expect that behavior.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by skyde on Saturday August 21, 2021 @03:30PM
(#28259814)
For the raft algorithm to be correct Fsync is required on a majority of node otherwise you are technically not implementing Raft.
The reason is that in Raft if a node acknowledges to the leader that it wrote something to the log it must not later accept a different write in the same log position.
This mean if for some reason server rebooted with dirty buffered writes that could not be flushed in time. it’s supposed to forgot everything it know and rejoin the cluster using a brand new node id.
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by alexchamberlain on Saturday August 21, 2021 @01:33PM
(#28258858)
Each write should be fsync'd to the WAL, right?
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by stingraycharles on Saturday August 21, 2021 @04:02PM
(#28260068)
Yes but those can happen at the convenience of the particular node, not necessarily as a globally chrckpointed fsync()
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by refenestrator on Saturday August 21, 2021 @04:19PM
(#28260230)
Then you're sacrificing consistency guarantees. If less than a majority have committed a write, it could be lost while the cluster still has a quorum up.
Waiting to report success until a majority have committed allows you to make guarantees with a straight face.. "it will probably be committed in the near future" is not the same thing.
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by rubiquity on Saturday August 21, 2021 @08:07PM
(#28261755)
Not necessarily. As long as your quorums always overlap you can have weaker commit requirements. See the FPaxos paper and some of Heidi Howard’s blogs for more on this.
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by jimsimmons on Sunday August 22, 2021 @02:33AM
(#28263397)
FPaxos requires commit quorum and subsequent promise request quorum to intersect. It doesn't bring any significant thruput benefits
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by rubiquity on Sunday August 22, 2021 @11:50AM
(#28266447)
I didn't say FPaxos brought throughput benefits. I pointed out that you can still have a correct implementation without requiring majority quorums.
But since you brought it up, FPaxos can have both lower latency and higher throughput than MultiPaxos/Raft[0] ;)
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by jimsimmons on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:00PM
(#28270079)
Great link. Need to look into what WPaxos is.
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by jimsimmons on Saturday August 21, 2021 @02:42PM
(#28259386)
You don't understand Raft. Quorum has to fsync for commit
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by rubiquity on Saturday August 21, 2021 @08:19PM
(#28261814)
It reads like you and GP are talking about two different things. You’re talking about Raft specifics and the GP seems to be talking about a Vertical Paxos like setup where Raft is used for configuration and the data path uses another replication algorithm such as Primary-Backup or Chain Replication.
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by jimsimmons on Sunday August 22, 2021 @02:35AM
(#28263409)
Hmmm that sorta makes sense I guess. Sorta because raft is a replication algorithm. If you don't use raft in datapath you don't get any of its guarantees
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by rubiquity on Sunday August 22, 2021 @11:53AM
(#28266468)
Most data paths don't need consensus for replication. You can implement ACID Transactions on top of many other replication algorithms for example. Ultimately the choice comes down to read/write ratios. Chain Replication has much better read throughout than Paxos and Raft.
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by jimsimmons on Sunday August 22, 2021 @06:02PM
(#28270095)
I see. What's the catch though. Sounds like free lunch. Is there some gotcha with partition tolerance?
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by rubiquity on Sunday August 22, 2021 @09:24PM
(#28271437)
It’s the case of 2F+1 versus F+1. Paxos/Raft offer fault tolerance where as other replication algorithms don’t. If you have a node failure in Primary-Backup or Chain for example you need to reconfigure before committing more writes. However in practice and certain environments reconfiguration can be faster than or the same as a leader failure in Paxos that requires running Phase 1 again.
Re:IceFireDB: Distributed disk storage database based on Raf...
by jimsimmons on Monday August 23, 2021 @02:37PM
(#28280102)
Got it, makes sense. To the extent this can be formalized, I feel this is a much better alternative than consensus based approaches