News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by gruez on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:46PM (#28249072)
>Capitalism is predicated on the idea of perpetual and infinite growth

First sentence from wikipedia:

>Capitalism is an economic system based on the private ownership of the means of production and their operation for profit.

How does this predicate "on the idea of perpetual and infinite growth"? I mean, it'll be nice if the economy grew infinitely, but I'd still want to invest my money into production even if that didn't exist.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by jfengel on Friday August 20, 2021 @03:05PM (#28250087)
Would you be able to invest? I'm trying to work through the thought experiment.

Suppose we've reached a point where the population has stabilized and all natural resources were being used at the sustainable rate. What production would you be able to buy? Would the current owners sell it to you? Would you be able to accumulate enough capital to induce them to sell?

Obviously the definition of capitalism doesn't include "perpetual growth", but it does seem like a reasonable extrapolation about the world. At the time capitalism was defined, indefinite growth was realistic, and easy to assume axiomatically. I'm not sure what capitalism looks like if that assumption fails.

I'm also not sure what it looks like for that assumption to fail, since "production" also includes creativity which isn't limited by natural resources. You can always invest in new books, video games, etc which are effectively unlimited.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by bluGill on Friday August 20, 2021 @03:45PM (#28250565)
I'd invest in something more efficient. If I can find a better way to turn the natural resources into something else can make a profit.

Or I'd invest in games/movies/art. People are always interested in something new even if the plot 3000 years old.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by jfengel on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:22PM (#28251558)
In your first paragraph, that's the point that the OP was making: you're assuming that we won't reach a point of diminishing returns. That's not guaranteed.

We might be able to guarantee infinite creativity... but will you be able to invest in it? If you're not the one writing the game/movie/novel, why would the artist permit you to invest and reap the benefit of their creativity?

Until recently, you could gain that power by owning key industries: the cinemas, the advertising agencies, etc. But those middle men are increasingly squeezed out; what would you offer that they can't get elsewhere? They'd cut your marginal return to the bone by playing you off against other people who have money to invest but nothing of their own to invest in.

In the best case, the resources would be distributed well enough that you could write your own novel, or whatever creative project, and not care about who will pay for it. In the worst case, you could find that all of the money ends up in the hands of a very few, who would out-compete you for any investment opportunity that arose.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by gruez on Friday August 20, 2021 @06:15PM (#28252013)
>If you're not the one writing the game/movie/novel, why would the artist permit you to invest and reap the benefit of their creativity?

AAA games are expensive to make, so are blockbuster movies. Even for non AAA/blockbuster movies, you'd still need some sort of financing. If UBI isn't a thing you'd need to finance your living somehow, which limits you to working part-time or requiring a substantial savings fund. novels might be fine, but you'd still might want a publisher for an advance or PR.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by nicoffeine on Friday August 20, 2021 @02:48PM (#28249863)
Modern capitalism depends on fiat currency and investment from those with capital. Currency loses value over time to inflation, so investors are always trying to get better returns against a baseline. Even at 3% per year, consumption has to double every 16 years if investors only want to break even.

So, it's not "nice" if the economy grows, it's an absolute requirement to keep investors interested.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by gruez on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:00PM (#28251350)
>Currency loses value over time to inflation, so investors are always trying to get better returns against a baseline. Even at 3% per year, consumption has to double every 16 years if investors only want to break even.

The math does not check out. 1.03^16 = 1.6, not 2 like you'd expect if it was "double".

Moreover, inflation only necessitates that the money supply grow infinitely, not economic activity and/or resources. If we doubled the bank balance of everyone overnight, and the price of everything doubled, that's not really "growth" in any meaningful sense.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by imtringued on Friday August 20, 2021 @03:49PM (#28250603)
It isn't. People keep credit (aka bank money) in their bank accounts even at negative nominal interest rates. The problem is the insistence on positive interest because of moral attachments to the idea of frugality.

Central banks target positive inflation because of the inability to cut interest rates below zero.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by nicoffeine on Friday August 20, 2021 @03:34PM (#28250420)
For the downvoters:

"The single most important question in investing this year is whether the rampant inflation of the moment is temporary, as the Federal Reserve believes, or marks a historic shift. I argued last week that we are on the cusp of a major change and long-run inflation is now more likely."

https://www.wsj.com/articles/if-inflation-is-coming-here-is-...

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by betwixthewires on Friday August 20, 2021 @04:31PM (#28251057)
Why have I been seeing so much attention given to voting in threads on HN these days? Is there an influx from Reddit or something by a bunch of people who didn't take the time to learn the etiquette here? We speak only when there's something to be said, vote only based on the quality of the comment and move on. You don't need to address downvoters. If you had something to address them with it should've been in your original comment, then maybe they wouldn't have downvoted.
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by nicoffeine on Friday August 20, 2021 @09:03PM (#28253131)
> Be kind. Don't be snarky. Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine. Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by betwixthewires on Friday August 20, 2021 @10:46PM (#28253669)
What in particular is this in response to?
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by nicoffeine on Saturday August 21, 2021 @09:15AM (#28256767)
If you’re going to arbitrate etiquette, lead by example. Following part of it when it suits you defeats the point of bringing it up.
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by betwixthewires on Saturday August 21, 2021 @05:17PM (#28260655)
OK, but what in particular did I say that you felt the need to quote rules?