News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by betwixthewires on Friday August 20, 2021 @05:04PM (#28251388)
That's ridiculous.

While I agree with you that these problems are caused by using houses as a speculative vehicle, "only the initial sale should be profitable" would cause way way worse problems than this. This is a very ill thought out proposal, hammers destroy everything but nails.

The actual solutions to this problem are things like higher taxes on second properties, high capital gains tax on selling more than X homes in your lifetime (similar to the lifetime gift tax cap) or on "short term" speculative buys, reduction in ridiculous code and regulations on what sort of shelters people can live in/build for themselves, and I'm sure others I haven't thought of or heard of.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by Dma54rhs on Friday August 20, 2021 @02:50PM (#28249890)
It's much more insane that so many laws don't allow or discourage people building a shelter from.
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by dudul on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:32PM (#28248869)
Do you think the same about selling food for profit? or clothing? or medical care?
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by mediaman on Friday August 20, 2021 @02:15PM (#28249472)
They don't normally think through the consequences of this type of policy.

What happens when you're barred from selling it for more than you paid?

The seller will have a price cap but will have hundreds of people who want to buy it.

How do they choose?

Maybe lavish off-the-book gifts, or maybe they choose based on how the person looks, or perhaps they arrange consulting contracts to make up payment afterward.

Would you invest in your house if you knew you couldn't get any return on it? Or would you let it run to shambles?

Imagine you were a landlord renting a unit out and a new law prohibited selling it for more than you bought it. How would that impact your decision to maintain it? Would you spend money on updating the interiors, replacing carpets, putting up new siding, if you planned on selling it within a few years?

Suppose every landlord did this. What would a typical city block start looking like?

And so on.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by imtringued on Friday August 20, 2021 @04:20PM (#28250944)
That's why any sane person only wants to tax the land because taxing land reduces the value of land and increases the importance of the building on top of the land.

When you tax land people don't suddenly stop producing more land.

Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by mediaman on Friday August 27, 2021 @01:19PM (#28330483)
Agreed on land tax. High taxes on land helps eliminate empty parking lots and other unproductive uses, and so long as zoning cooperates, encourages density.
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by imtringued on Friday August 20, 2021 @04:16PM (#28250896)
Those are reproducible. You can make more food. You can't produce land.
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by dudul on Friday August 20, 2021 @04:33PM (#28251072)
You can build upward. You can actually "make" land like in Monaco for example. The land is there, its just the way its used. And making it so you can't sell for profit would decincitive new construction projects even more.
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by beeboop on Friday August 20, 2021 @09:54PM (#28253376)
Agreed. It's really sick that we turn an essential of living into something that costs $850k on average in the city I live in.
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by vasco on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:47PM (#28249099)
And how do you propose we define real up to date cost?
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by amrcnimgrnt on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:30PM (#28248832)
Why?
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by ausbah on Friday August 20, 2021 @03:53PM (#28250644)
i am sympathetic to this viewpoint because the incentives for homeowners are mostly orthogonal to that of increasing home ownership for all. why would a homeowner support increasing the supply of housing when it drives down the price of their home?
Re:Home Prices Are Now Higher Than the Peak of the 2000s Hou... by amrcnimgrnt on Monday August 23, 2021 @11:01AM (#28276833)
Because I have children that I would like for one day to be able to afford a house.

I mean, OPs idea was silly beyond belief. Even the socialists dont say: "The only person who can profit from this are the capitalists (necessarily) who first build this. The buyer can't make a profit from the re-sale".

I met a builder once that you probably have never heard of. He is a billionaire. He can profit from the sale of homes, but my parent's can't? Never mind that the tripling of the price of my parent's home over the last 22 years was driven by silly economic policies. Otherwise the house would have appreciated maybe 50%.