News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:People Who Draw Lines on Maps Are the Problem by tdeck on Friday August 20, 2021 @04:53AM (#28244056)
> sometimes they really do know what's best--that is their job afterall.

not: That's the expert's job, not the politician's. A politician's job is to secure and maintain enough support from critical stakeholders so that they can stay in power. Depending on how the society is organized, that might mean making many people happy with successful public policies, or only a few people happy in the army command, megadonor class, central committee, etc...

Re:People Who Draw Lines on Maps Are the Problem by h2odragon on Friday August 20, 2021 @08:36AM (#28245299)
I would say the politician's job is finding workable compromises between conflicting peoples and agendas. A technician of the polis .

Rulers need power so they won't need to compromise.

Re:People Who Draw Lines on Maps Are the Problem by mdp2021 on Friday August 20, 2021 @10:28AM (#28246420)
Sorry but I feel it important to correct one detail:

-- experts are the ones supposed to be reliable about the outcomes¹; politicians should be the ones reliable about the weighs to choose as multipliers to said outcomes in decision.

How good one is at one's job, it still depends on the individual.

--

¹That's not exactly «knowing what's best». Experts are often biased in a field. To the doctor it may easily be "not to overcrowd the hospital", to the economist "not to undercrowd the commercial areas".

Re:People Who Draw Lines on Maps Are the Problem by tdeck on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:52PM (#28249168)
Oops meant to write "nit" but my phone didn't think that was a likely word.