Re:Tensions rise as Iranian dams cut off Iraqi water supplies
by sudosysgen on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:28PM
(#28238230)
The Islamic empire was not ethnic and spanned those cultures yet worked pretty well.
Re:Tensions rise as Iranian dams cut off Iraqi water supplies
by dustypotato on Friday August 20, 2021 @06:58AM
(#28244711)
The caliphates fragmented pretty soon due to revolts.
I've been thinking a lot about this problem generically, and I'm wondering if there's more formally published elsewhere. How well do multicultural polities work compared to more homogeneous polities (polities that crudely map to an ethnic group)? I'm not strongly for or against any particular position, but it seems like there are efficiencies to more homogeneous entities and I believe one of the criticisms of the colonization of the Middle East (and the purported explanation for why there is so much conflict in the Middle East) was that the European powers drew borders (deliberately, IIRC) that were multicultural rather than ethnic. If this is true, it seems like it would contradict the multicultural thesis, but it seems to be espoused most frequently by multiculturalists.
Does anyone know of anyone who has written about this more comprehensively?
EDIT: This comment downthread seems related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28234364