News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Awingu: Simpler Citrix alternative by rcarmo on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:32AM (#28231329)
All the HTML5/canvas clients are pretty much stopgaps for light use. Only a native client will give you a decent experience, since ICA/RDP etc. needs proper hardware access to accelerate rendering, and a canvas in Chrome just isn’t it.
Re:Awingu: Simpler Citrix alternative by imagine99 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:45AM (#28235291)
I know you are correct but I don't really see why it's gotta (continue to) be like that. If legacy protocols like RDP and PCoIP aren't up to a modern, multi-4k-monitor workstation environment, this field is ripe for disruption. Endpoints with surprisingly small footprints can stream multiple 4k videos and support cloud gaming... a potential sourxe for ideas? I would think that there is a lot more potential that even newer protocols such as Blast Extreme are only beginning to scratch...
Re:Awingu: Simpler Citrix alternative by rcarmo on Thursday August 19, 2021 @04:13PM (#28238770)
I think you’re wrong to say RDP isn’t up to scratch. I do _optimize_ it, but it now encompasses modern video and audio codecs with very low latency, and it is certainly good enough for me to view training videos, do full screen browser scrolling at a very good clip, etc.

Also, it keeps getting improved-today’s RDP has very little to do with what we had five years ago.

Re:Awingu: Simpler Citrix alternative by imagine99 on Friday August 20, 2021 @09:54AM (#28245978)
Note that I didn't say it isn't up to scratch. I was referring to others in this thread who said the protocols were subpar. Although RDP still does not support full-screen use on, say, 2 out of 3 monitors in a multi-monitor setup (the 3rd screen being used locally) without the famous VMware Workstation hack.

RDP works well for me personally in a variety of use cases (albeit none of them are graphics intensive) - however, user feedback I have received especially from engineers and designers has shown that they are unhappy with it.

For example you cannot (anymore) use discrete graphics in an RDP session (e.g. in certain CAD or 3D software). I think this was under development but got removed, iirc. Other protocols like the one used by Splashtop do support this but in our tests RDP on W2k19 still provided higher fps and a smoother experience than Splashtop (with the downside that some software wouldn't start over RDP because it couldn't directly access the graphics card).

Are there any particular optimisations you do to RDP beyond what can be done in the "Experience" and "Display" tabs of mstsc.exe?

Re:Awingu: Simpler Citrix alternative by hughrr on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:40AM (#28231365)
yep agree. But why deploy LOB SaaS browser applications on Citrix? It doesn’t add up.
Re:Awingu: Simpler Citrix alternative by rcarmo on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:42AM (#28231384)
It’s typically about control and auditing. You can record entire sessions, for instance, and limit the ability to scrape sensitive customer data. The list goes on and on if you have a security mindset.
Re:Awingu: Simpler Citrix alternative by hughrr on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:51AM (#28231428)
I’ve seen that promoted but never implemented or used successfully.

As for data exfiltration I’ve worked in the defence sector in IT which has pretty stringent security controls in place. At the same time it’s very easy to do without much effort.

The key thing with this technology is box ticking to say you have a policy in place and to avoid liability, not to solve the problem effectively. This is only done through picking ethical, rigorous and professional staff. But that doesn’t scale because they are the 1% which is the real problem. So back to liability box ticking.