News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by version_five on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:42PM (#28226827)
One thing I'd add to the article is that a key feature of the Marlow novels is their meandering plots. I read once that Raymond Chandler stories are about the journey, not the destination, so basically you're following Marlow around as he does stuff (that is mentioned in the article). The stuff he does is locally interesting, and it makes the stories good. But judging the stories based on their plot synopsis doesn't really get you anywhere. I've read all the Marlow novels, a while ago now, but I'd be challenged to give a decent summary of any of them. Its about the individual scenes.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by smackeyacky on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @06:20PM (#28227873)
This is very much my experience of those novels. Not quite as opaque as Conrad's "Heart of darkness" but I get the idea that you are supposed to be as much in the dark about what is happening to Marlowe as Marlowe is himself. It helps with the immersion.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by twelvechairs on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @06:41PM (#28228062)
TV has shifted this way, where its now common to have long running series where different writers, directors, etc. across every episode. Everything is logical in its immediate context but can seem illogical in the broader context of the entire series/show.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by mixmastamyk on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @06:51PM (#28228142)
Yes, lots of characters change at random, just when you think you know them.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by version_five on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @07:30PM (#28228517)
I find this in a lot of Netflix shows, where the season is ostensibly building to some revelation about who the killer or mole or whoever is, but each episode plays out like it was based only on prompts from the previous ones and not according to some planned story arc. At the end you don't see everything fall into place, you learn that there was a relationship that was not alluded to in any way through the rest of the season that suddenly makes someone the killer.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by wrp on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @09:11PM (#28229233)
Exquisite Corpse the miniseries! It might be interesting to do that deliberately.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by fenomas on Thursday August 19, 2021 @02:58AM (#28231145)
Yeah, he talks a lot about this in his essays - one quote I liked was "a good mystery is one you'd read even if the end was missing". He was definitely rebelling against the classical mystery format, where every clue must be clearly presented so that the reader can guess whodunit.