News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Modern LZ Compression (2019) by axiolite on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:53AM (#28218661)
Sounds like you're comparing multi-threaded zstd to other utilities that are single-threaded (e.g. gzip instead of pigz).

I duped /usr/share/dict/words into an 8GB file and did a couple tests on the old system I'm on:

  8589934592  original
  3075315128  pigz -1       1m0.44s
  2926825272  zstdmt -3     2m37.52s
  2877549999  pigz -3       1m28.94s
Re:Modern LZ Compression (2019) by lifthrasiir on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:56AM (#28218678)
Zstd by default is single-threaded. Just in case though...

    8,826,654,133       original
    3,033,695,892  0:22 zstd 1.3.3 -3 -T4
    3,025,746,073  1:21 zstd 1.3.3 -3 -T1 (default)
    3,017,972,162  1:05 zstd 1.5.0 -3 -T1 (default)
    3,013,860,663  1:23 zstd 1.5.0 -3 --single-thread
It is just no match.

EDIT: axiolite wanted to see --single-thread and while my Linux box only has an older zstd (1.3.3) without that option I realized I do have a Windows executable for recent zstd (1.5.0). Both executables have run in the same machine but I can't guarantee anything about the 1.5.0 binary.

Re:Modern LZ Compression (2019) by axiolite on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:59AM (#28218688)
zstd is NOT single-threaded by default. It's dual threaded. You have to pass the --single-thread option to make it single threaded.

I think you need to try pigz...

Re:Modern LZ Compression (2019) by lifthrasiir on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:10AM (#28218742)
--single-thread probably doesn't do what you think, it forces zstd to serialize I/O with the compression job and it doesn't mean compression itself is multi-threaded with -T1 [EDIT]. I can't try that anyway because my zstd version is slightly lower (1.3.3), but I can try pigz:

    3,664,854,169  0:42 pigz -1 -p4
    3,664,854,169  0:28 pigz -1 -p8 (default, also probably the max possible with my box)
Now I'm very curious where you got your copy of zstdmt. (I'm using stock Ubuntu packages for all of them.)

[EDIT] Was "it doesn't make compression itself multi-threaded", which can falsely imply that --single-thread seemingly enables multi-threaded compression but it doesn't ;)

Re:Modern LZ Compression (2019) by axiolite on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:21AM (#28218796)
Using stock RHEL7/EPEL packages: zstd-1.5.0-1.el7.x86_64 On an old Athlon II X4 615e right now.

The difference in our results certainly is curious.

Re:Modern LZ Compression (2019) by lifthrasiir on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:31AM (#28218844)
Very interesting. It might be the case that zstd optimizes more for recent machines; zstd famously uses four different compression streams to maximize instruction-level parallelism and that might not work well in older machines. I haven't seen any machine where zstd is significantly slower than it should, but those machines I could test came from 2013 or later. Or either the RHEL package might have been optimized for recent machines. It would be interesting to test a binary optimized for the current machine (-march=native -mtune=native).
Re:Modern LZ Compression (2019) by hexxagone on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @11:58AM (#28223110)
pigz is no match for zstd...