News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Measuring 'Return on Investment' of Various College Degrees by rahimnathwani on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:08AM (#28218411)
NYT says the authors define the earnings premium by reference to a typical HS grad. But folks who can gain acceptance into a good program at a good school would (after 4 years) earn more than a typical HS grad, even if they skipped college.

Why attribute 100% of the uplift to the degree?

Re:Measuring 'Return on Investment' of Various College Degrees by irjustin on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:21AM (#28218799)
Is there another thing you would attribute it to?

It's not hard to simply ask "of this profession, what is the salary of those w/ a degree, and those w/o" at the national level

Re:Measuring 'Return on Investment' of Various College Degrees by rahimnathwani on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @10:59AM (#28221959)
Imagine there are two groups of 30-year-olds:

A) Those who were offered university places, but decided not to go.

B) Those who were not offered university places.

I would expect group A to have a significant 'earnings premium' over group B. Even though neither group attended university, group A are more likely to be smart, hard working, lucky, or whatever drives career success.

If you want to estimate the earnings premium of a university degree, you have to compare the folks who went to university with other folks just like them, i.e. with folks in group A. Not with a mixture of groups A and B.

> Is there another thing you would attribute it to?

Yes, some of the earnings premium is due to the students pre-university chances of success.

> It's not hard to simply ask "of this profession, > what is the salary of those w/ a degree, and those w/o" at the national level

This wouldn't measure the thing we're trying to measure, because it suffers from selection bias.