[1] the infrastructure bill that’s looking to pass, while it gives much needed funding to public transit, still centers car-centric planning, and nothing paradigm-shifting (e.g. a comprehensive regional high speed rail network, a dedicated bus line on every street, a protected bike lane on every arterial) will likely come from it.
Happy to tax one option to support a better option.
In a social practice sense I'd prefer transparency to see the tax money actually making a better future. But this is often lost or not communicated.
If I say "I will give you $20 to not drive" or "I will take $20 from you if you drive", the only thing that really matters is that there is a $20 price differential between two actions so you will be at a $20 disadvantage to do the current thing regardless of how you word it.
Money and wealth is relative so the actual final amount doesn't matter as much as how much you have compared to the average person.