Re:As cities grow in size, the poor 'get nothing at all': study
by Clewza313 on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @09:39PM
(#28216843)
It's not "wrong", you're just parsing it differently. The title means that the poor don't enjoy any additional benefits from that growth, since their expenses scale accordingly; thus theie net growth in disposable income is "nothing at all".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:As cities grow in size, the poor 'get nothing at all': study
by arc-in-space on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @10:25PM
(#28217146)
That is certainly the original meaning, but do you think that after seeing the headlined "nothing at all" before reading further, most people will arrive at this exact understanding?
There is a very good reason the title used quotation marks, and it's not because it's a quote.
Re:As cities grow in size, the poor 'get nothing at all': study
by aaron695 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:29AM
(#28218229)
Expenses don't change with city size with a few exceptions. Housing being the only one they look at, which I think is fair. With housing costs removed they say -
"The poorest two deciles in bigger cities make about the same income as their counterparts in smaller cities"
Which does match the title.
I think there are a few obvious problems with this. But as a paper it's a good start. I object to the strongly worded title, but it's not wrong from the paper.