But I don't know for sure. Someone should research this... but they would need to be very skeptical and probing, not just taking people's statements at face value.
That's not to say that literally every single neighborhood would benefit from upzoning, but the areas most in need of upzoning do have this property.
Yet homeowners oppose it. This suggests that their arguments against zoning are sincere. People genuinely do not want more density in their neighborhoods. It's not entirely a cynical ploy to boost home values.
I'm happy for them. That's all well and good, but when you buy a plot of land you buy that land, you don't get controlling interest in the whole neighborhood.
These shenanigans are starting to get cracked down upon at the state level, because of course local fiefdoms are going to craft self-serving policies. In aggregate, however, they ultimately strangle the economic potential of the state. There's a great writeup of how the state of California is bringing discipline to the (lack of) statewide housing development here[1].
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/LosAngeles/comments/nqpc91/lets_tal...
There's an old saying, tax something, get less of it. Often used to support some atavistic conservative position, it nonetheless seems relevant here.
1. We want more affordable housing.
2. The cost of land is a major problem.
3. So, tax the land value mostly out of existence and don't tax the improvements at all.
It may sound crazy but why not give it a go? The key idea is that land is the one thing that you don't get less of when you tax it. Nor can you get more of it by taxing it less.This is not my idea, it's based on economic ideas over a century old, although I wouldn't go so far as to say the only tax should be land value. Just maybe see if specifically real estate and its taxes could be unfucked in this way.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism
This is almost too perfect:
"One day in 1871 George went for a horseback ride and stopped to rest while overlooking San Francisco Bay. He later wrote of the revelation that he had:
I asked a passing teamster, for want of something better to say, what land was worth there. He pointed to some cows grazing so far off that they looked like mice, and said, "I don't know exactly, but there is a man over there who will sell some land for a thousand dollars an acre." Like a flash it came over me that there was the reason of advancing poverty with advancing wealth. With the growth of population, land grows in value, and the men who work it must pay more for the privilege"
I can't imagine locking in the price and paying homeowners the current value of their land.
>> People genuinely do not want more density in their neighborhoods
How is that not NIMBYism ?https://ips-dc.org/report-towering-excess/
I think the 61% of people who want affordable housing and homeless housing recognize these failures, which is why they want a more direct solution.
[1]: https://www.boston.gov/departments/assessing/filing-property...
Also, the flip side of the argument is that not building lots of housing doesn't necessarily mean that people aren't going to move there. If you have a bunch of housing that is "not for existing Bostonians" as the page says, and it's getting rented/sold, one common reason is that your city is an attractive employment location for high-paying jobs (for Boston I'd guess tech and biotech) and so people are moving in. Not building new housing for those people doesn't immediately make your city unattractive; it just means that this crowd of people with high-paying jobs will take over your existing housing stock because they can outbid "existing Bostonians."
I don't think most people understand that if market-rate housing isn't built en masse, and there's just 'affordable housing' allowed, the result will be mostly insanely expensive housing for the vast majority and a small token effort at affordable housing. End result? Millions of people paying ~50% of their income in rent.