News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by hetman on Saturday August 14, 2021 @11:12PM (#28185976)
Everything we have seen so far seems to indicate that you get maximum productivity when you pair human and AI, rather than having either on its own. What that means in practice is that (at least until someone actually develops GAI) aspects of programming may be automatable but you'll always want to keep a human in the loop somewhere to get maximum productivity. This should be true until society's need for programmers becomes saturated... but since programming is essentially itself automation, it's hard to imagine that need subsiding any time soon.
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by singingfish on Sunday August 15, 2021 @01:23AM (#28186457)
Yes, AI (or even better what I like to call Artificial Stupidity - naive implementations that get you 90% there) are a great cognitive prosthetic, but in my experience should not be relied on.
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by gajomi on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:43AM (#28186700)
I have been using the phrase "Artificial Stupidity" as well, but with the opposite meaning. Specifically I like to think of human-like artificial stupidity as a challenge for machine intelligence, in which an algorithm is able to replicate the rather sophisticated and incredibly entangled logic, intuitions and calculus of humans at the height of their stupidity. This seems to me a much greater challenge than the standard sort of supervised learning problems in that a truly stupid AI must be able to imagine latent variables that allow it to explain away real world observations in a way that is both statistically implausible but casually serendipitous to their stupid peers. This seems to me to be a requirement for any kind of useful AGI.
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by Florin_Andrei on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:29AM (#28186884)
You could easily generate stupid statements on demand. Just post a video on Youtube on a related theme, and scrape the comments.
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by Areading314 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:37AM (#28186676)
A better name for AI is "pattern recognition" because thats what it is. There is nothing intelligent about it.
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by wruza on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:01AM (#28186782)
What is intelligent about natural pattern recognition? /s

Sarcasm aside, your definition is too low-level, as if we called brains just braincells. Pattern recognition is a building block of AI like a logic gate is a building block of a CPU.

Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday August 15, 2021 @05:17AM (#28187356)
If you studied formal logic, you understand what logic gates do and what a CPU can do.

We don't understand brains or braincells - how many operations per cecond can a braincell do? What type of operations? How many bytes does it store? We don't know.

Can we replace a single braincell with a chip and get them to act the same?

Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by wruza on Sunday August 15, 2021 @08:44AM (#28188333)
Likely not, but that was not my point either, it was just an non-stretchable analogy.

AI is not a single network usually, it is a pipeline of networks of different kinds, see e.g. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=P1IcaBn3ej0 (seek to 1:35 for beginning of an architecture overview). You can’t call it “just pattern matching” without fetching it too far.

Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by Areading314 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:41PM (#28191832)
ok, its an algorithm that makes use of pattern matching
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by Florin_Andrei on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:30AM (#28186887)
Do we do much beyond pattern recognition?
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by visarga on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:26AM (#28187892)
> in my experience [AI] should not be relied on

Have you considered all uses of AI or just a few that you encountered in your experience? AI automates lots of unpleasant manual work.

Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by _fat_santa on Sunday August 15, 2021 @10:21AM (#28188956)
> AI automates lots of unpleasant manual work.

Github Copilot is a great example of this IMO. When you're writing code it seems to be on a 90/10 of 80/20 split where 10-20% of your code is the actual important bits that you have to pay attention to and the other 80-90% is all the common patterns, components and conventions around the important code.

AI is fantastic for the 80-90% of that code that I really don't care about. I can focus my energy on the 10-20% of the code that is really important and let the AI code the other 80-90% that is mostly glue and filler.

Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by bpodgursky on Sunday August 15, 2021 @12:17AM (#28186221)
My main problem with this theory is that so many people want it to be true; very hard for me to see anyone doing dispassionate analysis of whether humans will be valuable in the loop long-term.
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by rytill on Sunday August 15, 2021 @12:50AM (#28186356)
What do you mean long-term? In the short and medium term (5y), humans being in the loop is highly likely to be valuable, as you seem to agree with. Long term is very difficult to predict. AGI changes everything instantly.

If you’re saying “it seems like people just want humans to be valuable, and the human race’s thinking seems very anthropocentric”, I definitely agree. It’s hard to separate a person’s inherent need to be important from dispassionate analysis in general.

Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by Florin_Andrei on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:31AM (#28186892)
With AGI looming at the horizon, any long term predictions are baseless. The event horizon is somewhere at +20 years.
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by beebmam on Sunday August 15, 2021 @12:14AM (#28186209)
I'm not so sold on your premise. I think there are trade-offs when using AI for software dev, like with copilot.
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by iratewizard on Sunday August 15, 2021 @01:17AM (#28186432)
Copilot is simply a poor application of it. Searching the internet for a stack exchange answer is a rudimentary example of pairing an AI with a human. Modern chess GMs use stockfish to study positions. Maybe a future version of that will be more similar to stockfish for code you're writing or problems you're debugging.
Re:Software Dev Can't Be Automated – It’s a Creative Process... by fulafel on Monday August 16, 2021 @10:17AM (#28198391)
A lot of the currently mainstream advanced compiler and programming language tech was called AI when first developed.