Re:Spotify Sued For Patent Infringement Just Weeks After Ent...
by rwmj on Thursday July 28, 2011 @02:45PM
(#2818304)
Back in 1992 we used to stream music over the network of Sun machines at St. Andrews university[1].
The way we did it was pretty trivial: just piping into rsh from and to /dev/audio. However it was certainly streaming of music by anyone's definition.
[1] Making the admins of said network mighty pissed off in the process -- I believe the whole campus was on 10 Mbps at the time.
Re:Spotify Sued For Patent Infringement Just Weeks After Ent...
by kenjackson on Thursday July 28, 2011 @02:57PM
(#2818360)
From what I can tell reading the patent, what you describe would not be prior art.
Two things would need to be present -- DRM of some sort. And music metadata.
These are two things that I suspect Spotify makes use of. I suspect you probably didn't at St Andrews for your streaming, but let me know if you did.
Re:Spotify Sued For Patent Infringement Just Weeks After Ent...
by monochromatic on Thursday July 28, 2011 @03:12PM
(#2818441)
Just a semantic thing, but it is still prior art... it's just probably not prior art that, on its own, is enough to invalidate these claims. It could still be relevant for obviousness purposes.
Re:Spotify Sued For Patent Infringement Just Weeks After Ent...
by zach on Friday July 29, 2011 @12:32AM
(#2820215)
I know I happily streamed .au music from the sounds.sdsu.edu FTP server into /dev/audio (late at night, of course) in that era. Since it was an FTP server, I suppose there was a rough sort of DRM (maximum connections allowed) and metadata (directories and filenames describing the artist and song name). Even though I had seen a good deal of MBONE broadcasts, it was quite a novelty to hear a song streamed on demand.
Re:Spotify Sued For Patent Infringement Just Weeks After Ent...
by rwmj on Friday July 29, 2011 @03:28AM
(#2820591)
Fair enough, but given almost any thought at that time, we'd have thought of metadata (probably not DRM because we wouldn't have believed something so stupid was needed).
Once you've got a network, walkmans, a "mic" input, and a speaker, this stuff is obvious and that's the point.
Re:Spotify Sued For Patent Infringement Just Weeks After Ent...
by lukeschlather on Thursday July 28, 2011 @04:16PM
(#2818721)
That still doesn't make something clever enough to merit a patent.
One other comment: I really appreciate that techdirt actually included a claim from the patent. Most articles posted here just quote the title or the abstract, which is useless as far as determining what's covered and what's not.