News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by WalterBright on Friday August 13, 2021 @03:28PM (#28173418)
I don't see how hearsay evidence could ever be debunked. And even if a recording could be found of him saying that, he could always just say he was joking.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by dTal on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:09PM (#28176816)
You could find a guy saying "yeah I totally made that up". Or at least trace the origin of the rumor, and note that it doesn't plausibly connect with Osama's life. Or interview a bunch of people close to him who say they've never heard anything like that, and note that it's therefore implausible that a bunch of Americans somehow know. Or find the real reasons that he hated America, and note they're vastly more plausible and documented. Etc, etc.

This is a classic "Russell's teapot". We should not give any epistemological weight to unfalsifiable things. To debunk them, it suffices to demonstrate that there was never any evidence to begin with.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by bartread on Friday August 13, 2021 @04:03PM (#28173842)
> I don't see how hearsay evidence could ever be debunked.

Well, that's the thing, isn't it? Hearsay doesn't reach the necessary standard to be considered evidence in the first place in sensible forums, including most courts.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by Uhhrrr on Friday August 13, 2021 @04:31PM (#28174109)
Yes. But the other thing is debunking rumors is the task they set for themselves. And in these cases, they went for the dopamine hit of writing "FALSE" over the eternally annoying "Unconfirmed".
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by emodendroket on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:12PM (#28176833)
If the claim is true, the claimant should be able to produce evidence of it, such as someone who would have reason to know stating that it happened.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by brightball on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:16PM (#28177205)
My wife just told me she was going to bed.

It’s true. There’s no feasible way for me to prove it. Even if she were to record a statement saying that, indeed, she said that…she could be lying for some reason.

Most of what we experience in life every day isn’t provable. That doesn’t make it any less true. It’s just exposes a weakness in what a person is willing to consider as truth, which is that it depends entirely on your willingness to trust the source and very little to do with actual truth.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by emodendroket on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:21PM (#28177246)
I mean, if you video of Osama bin Laden telling me the story, or one of his associates were on the record with it, I'd find it plausible. In this case we have absolutely nothing.

This is rather elementary stuff. If you accept your "more expansive" version of the truth then I have to entertain pretty much any fantastical claim because it is impossible to disprove anything definitively.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by brightball on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:45PM (#28177367)
Doesn’t mean you have to accept it, it just means that there’s very little you can assert as false.

Snopes does that every day with very little to prove it other than the desires of its readers to agree with them.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by emodendroket on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:47PM (#28177384)
"False" is clearly shorthand for "there is no evidence that this is true."

If I wrote "brightball beats his wife" and then said you couldn't really say it was false because you couldn't prove it had never happened definitively it would be outrageous, right? Nobody would accept that as a reasonable argument.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by brightball on Saturday August 14, 2021 @06:37AM (#28179624)
Exactly. And it would be the same if you included the word “doesn’t” in that statement. It just means that it’s all hearsay and only the people involved know the real truth.

This is why gossip and rumors are such a powerful thing. We all want to think that what we know or what we heard is true, but very few people are willing to accept that what they heard might not be accurate. Especially once they have repeated it to someone else.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by emodendroket on Saturday August 14, 2021 @07:17AM (#28179761)
No. It’s not even hearsay. That’s the point.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by brightball on Saturday August 14, 2021 @09:15AM (#28180359)
And come on, “Unconfirmed” clearly means there is no evidence to confirm this.

“False” means not true.

I don’t expect anyone reading to interpret that differently.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by emodendroket on Saturday August 14, 2021 @09:59AM (#28180680)
So the existence of fairies and unicorns is merely "unconfirmed"? I would consider that term to mean that there is one reasonably credible report that has not been corroborated.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by brightball on Monday August 16, 2021 @04:24PM (#28202484)
Do you have any reports claiming to have seen them? Do you trust the source?
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by emodendroket on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:10PM (#28176822)
Well, I think it'd be sufficient to say there is no proof it happened, the same standard we use to say that there aren't little gnomes who collect up all the water and turn it into water vapor, causing it to rain.