News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by harpiaharpyja on Friday August 13, 2021 @03:13PM (#28173188)
Fact-checking is a dead end, a poor substitute for development of critical thinking skills in the broader population. It may be more challenging, but that's what we need to start working towards.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by tablespoon on Friday August 13, 2021 @05:02PM (#28174483)
> Fact-checking is a dead end, a poor substitute for development of critical thinking skills in the broader population. It may be more challenging, but that's what we need to start working towards.

Pretty sure that work was started thousands of years ago.

Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. IMHO, insisting the only solution is to increase "critical thinking" to unheard of levels is wishful thinking that mainly serves to shoot down necessary mitigations for the psychological and social failings of individuals and communities. Fact checking isn't a perfect institution, but nothing is.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by unclebucknasty on Friday August 13, 2021 @07:04PM (#28175914)
Good points. It would absolutely be helpful if more people thought more critically. However, even if we achieved that goal, we still can't allow bad actors to unleash a constant firehose of disinformation on society.

The truth can't be so hard to discover in a functioning society/democracy, and it shouldn't require an entire population to be expert critical thinkers who devote significant time undergoing epistemological exercises to discover base reality.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by ralph84 on Friday August 13, 2021 @04:17PM (#28173982)
Has there ever been a time in history when those in power desired critical thinking skills in the broader population? Those in power want a compliant population, not a questioning one.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by michaelt on Friday August 13, 2021 @06:01PM (#28175143)
Every politician wants voters to see through the other guy's propaganda.

And if voters pick up critical thinking skills as a side-effect of education that will get them high-paying jobs, what's not to like?

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by mbrumlow on Saturday August 14, 2021 @12:29AM (#28177909)
Nope, Every politician wants you to believe their propaganda more than the next politician.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by richk449 on Friday August 13, 2021 @04:29PM (#28174094)
I’m curious what you mean by this. Assuming you are American, do you think that Obama or Trump or Biden wish that the population was more compliant, and had weaker critical thinking? Why would that benefit them?

Most leaders think they are right, and I would think they would want enhanced critical thinking in the population so that the people would better appreciate the leaders rightness.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by hobs on Friday August 13, 2021 @04:53PM (#28174377)
That's so far from the truth it is comical - populism is literally appealing to the base and stupid indistinct and creating an environment hostile to intellectual thinking... and it's been kind of a big thing the last 100 years...
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by rustyminnow on Friday August 13, 2021 @04:59PM (#28174429)
Sure, the President of the United States holds an office with a lot of executive power, but there are plenty of other people with other forms of power that would have an interest in a compliant population.

I hate to beat the "evil-zillionaire" drum, but if you made your fortunes selling people juice-boxes they don't really need, you'd prefer it if they complicitly buy all the junk your ads tell them to buy instead of critically thinking "maybe I DON'T need another one"

Take also cult-leaders for example (or other con-men in power/leadership positions). If their followers possessed the critical thinking skills to see through their manipulations, they wouldn't have any followers. Complacency in this case is fundamental

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by richk449 on Friday August 13, 2021 @06:27PM (#28175487)
Okay, sure, cult leaders and juice box company executives don’t want critical thinking in the populace. I guess those aren’t who I think of when I think of the powerful.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by rustyminnow on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:11PM (#28177185)
Yes the President of The United States of America is the ONLY person with ANY power. Not the companies who spend billions of dollars lobbying to pass laws only in their own interest. Not the media moguls or tv personalities who can manipulate public perception on any issue. Not the lawmakers, the community leaders, people who directly affect other people's lives.

No, I can't imagine anybody would like it if folks were dim and complacent and just generally easy to fuck over

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by unclebucknasty on Friday August 13, 2021 @04:05PM (#28173864)
But, even critical thinking ability relies on good inputs. There must be some baseline of facts to work with.

I do agree however that fact-checking is extremely challenging, but for different reasons. That is, in a society that is being programmed to choose the reality/truth they prefer, you'll end up with cult-like belief systems that no amount of fact-checking will break through.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by exporectomy on Friday August 13, 2021 @05:00PM (#28174455)
You can do a lot with thought experiments that show logical inconsistencies in ideas without any actual knowledge of the facts.

Physics is a fairly clear example. It's hard to make all those equations work without creating paradoxes unless they actually model the real world correctly. If it was all fake but internally consistent, then even a small amount of observation could destroy the whole thing.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by unclebucknasty on Friday August 13, 2021 @06:43PM (#28175702)
>You can do a lot with thought experiments that show logical inconsistencies in ideas without any actual knowledge of the facts

Yes, what you're getting at there is "a priori" knowledge in epistemological-speak and I agree that it forms the basis for much of what we consider true.

But, even the ability to accurately conduct and assess the results of those experiments relies on some set of facts. Your physics example speaks to exactly that: i.e. there's a foundation of "rules" that underpins the field, much of which have been developed through rigorous observation, experimentation, mathematical proof, etc. These rules form the "accepted truths" through which we are able to think critically about new ideas.

So, while we can debate degree, it should be clear that there has to be some accepted base reality to make sense of anything. And, of course, in this thread analogies to science are a bit of a digression. That is, the topic is fact-checking sites, which are largely about dispelling disinformation/misinformation of the social/political variety. So, for instance, whether x politician did or did not do something can be important to know when trying to critically assess their fitness.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by exporectomy on Saturday August 21, 2021 @11:25PM (#28262614)
I'm not talking about commonly accepted physics knowledge but people contradicting themselves - essentially saying "A and not A are both true" without realizing it. Well, unless the a priori knowledge you're talking about is logic, but then we're in over my head.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by javert on Friday August 13, 2021 @04:20PM (#28174018)
For a critical thinker, the baseline facts come from the person's own direct experience. They have to.

For example, I probably wouldn't 100% believe that hundreds of people can cross the sky in a metal tube (i.e., modern jet airplane) if I had only been told about it. But I've seen it myself.

Another example: I've learned enough about technology to think the moon landings were feasible, and I've learned enough about society to think that a successful conspiracy around the moon landings is implausible. So I believe the moon landings happened.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by technothrasher on Friday August 13, 2021 @04:38PM (#28174213)
Won't relying on direct experience as a basis for critical thinking lead to all kinds of problems due to faulty perception and cognitive biases that we all share? Additionally, how are we to evaluate situations were are not likely to have any experience with? None of us have any experience with, say, the big bang or anything close to what the universe was like then, but can't we still come to many likely conclusions about it without any even indirect experience?

So doesn't critical thinking in fact have to have a baseline in something other than one's own direct experience? Rationality, possibly?

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by javert on Friday August 13, 2021 @05:23PM (#28174715)
Rationality is a process, but it has to have data to work with. That data comes from perception of the world (sight, hearing, etc.). There is no such thing as "pure" rationality without sense data to work with.

Evidence for the big bang ultimately comes from sense data. You have to integrate a lot of sense data into scientific theories, which then are integrated with other scientific theories, and so on. Science has gotten so far - but it all started out with simple experiments, eventually microscopes and weak telescopes, etc. and built from there.

Critical thinking allows you to overcome cognitive biases. Faulty perception is pretty easy to detect. A stick in a glass of water will look bent, but it's easy to figure out that it actually isn't bent.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by exporectomy on Friday August 13, 2021 @05:11PM (#28174577)
You should have multiple independent types of observation. If you only know about the metal tube idea from flying in one yourself, it might have been a simulation. You should have other facts that also support the same conclusion (eg. knowledge of aerodynamics, people quickly moving around the world, etc.) so that it would be hard for them all to be wrong in the same way. You don't have to witness it with your own eyes because, again, it would be hard for them all to create the same consistent lie from multiple perspectives even if they were conspiring.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by javert on Friday August 13, 2021 @05:16PM (#28174628)
I agree with that, yes.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by kelnos on Friday August 13, 2021 @05:45PM (#28174950)
> For example, I probably wouldn't 100% believe that hundreds of people can cross the sky in a metal tube (i.e., modern jet airplane) if I had only been told about it. But I've seen it myself.

By that reasoning, all the people who deny the moon landings happened are completely logical, no? And there should be a lot more of them, right? Hell, I've never even seen a rocket take off (outside of video broadcasts), let alone seen spacecraft in flight, so I shouldn't believe in the moon landings either, right?

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by javert on Friday August 13, 2021 @06:57PM (#28175851)
My explanation was incomplete, to make for a good and clear example.

If I hadn't seen airplanes and flown in them, I'd still be open to believing they exist. My belief would depend on what other evidence there is (broadly speaking), as in my example of the moon landings.

It's easier to make a strong judgment about the existence of airplanes, than about the moon landings. I'd argue that most things in life are more like airplanes in that regard.

Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by emodendroket on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:14PM (#28176844)
I have a lot of quibbles with "fact checking" as practiced as a distinct vertical in news sites, but in principle I don't find anything wrong with examining claims to determine whether they are true. To make it unnecessary you'd need not just critical thinking but also everyone constantly doing their own research, which would rather limit the number of things anyone could have an opinion about.
Re:Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles und... by pmoriarty on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:27PM (#28176918)
You can't critically think your way in to deciding what really happened at the Gulf of Tonkin[1], or whether the CIA organised fake vaccination drive to get Osama bin Laden's family DNA[2]

It's claims like these and dozens of others that are made every day that fact checkers need to verify, as few if any of us have the time or expertise to check all these claims ourselves.

[1] - https://www.usni.org/magazines/naval-history-magazine/2008/f...

[2] - https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/jul/11/cia-fake-vacci...