News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by 3pt14159 on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:52AM (#28168828)
Can someone please explain to me how just 75 thousand warfighters are able to take over a country with a population larger than Canada? Is it a question of arms? If so, why didn't we arm them before leaving?

Because the only conclusion I have with this whole mess is that Afgans do not want to resist the Taliban. I abhor war, but if this were happening in Canada people, men and women, would fight with whatever they could their hands on.

Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by throwaway0a5e on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:55AM (#28168866)
Because the population is letting them.

These people DGAF about "Afghanistan" the nation in the western sense. The nation is not a nation. It's a series of tribes, ethnicity and clans that happen to share an area that is all shaded one color on a map. Those groups are where their allegiances lie. They don't have a multi hundred year history of nationalism like European nations do. Furthermore lots of them don't really want a national government because national governments tend to try to steal power and control by these other institutions and homogenize things which they see as a negative.

Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by rafale on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:01AM (#28168939)
Less than 1000 poorly trained and armed guerrillero lead by Fidelo Castro managed to take Cuba when the Cuban army had over 35 thousands soldiers.

The disparity is even more crazy during the battle for Mosul that saw a few hundred ISIS fighters defeat 60k armed forces.

It depends on what are you fighting for. An ideal/belief or money.

Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by shadowtree on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:57AM (#28168888)
The Afghan population is on their side. The size of the "army" does not matter. The ANA (Afghan Army) has no willpower to fight, just bail when confronted.

The US overthrew the Taliban, but never "liberated" Afghanistan as most of the population was on the Talib side. The alternative was warlords and constant civil war.

...and Pakistan helped quite a bit too :)

Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by tut-urut-utut on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:10AM (#28169064)
Because the Taliban are an actual liberating army, fighting a bunch of traitors and foreign financed government [1] / army. Now that the main occupying forces are gone, Afghanistan is coming back to the state they always wanted to be.

[1] from the Afghan population point of view.

Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by yyyk on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:15AM (#28169116)
A) The US built the Afghan army and state so that it would be utterly dependent on US support, and later withdrew in such a way as to maximize Taliban advantages (e.g. by demanding the release of Taliban prisoners, withdrawing from bases at night without informing the ANA etc.). On the other side, Taliban has full state support from Pakistan which never wavered and was smart enough to know how to manage them politically (something the US is really really bad at and is at the root of US failure, not just in AfPak).

B) Smart warlords knew where the wind was blowing when the US decided to withdraw, and defected to the other side. Oh, and previously, the Afghan president was encouraged to alienate the warlords. Though on this, guilt is only shared, since both Ghani and the US wanted to act so stupidly.

C) It's not 75 thousand, that estimate has no legs to stand on, but that's much less important.

Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by engineer_22 on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:58AM (#28168905)
The Afghan "Army" was a bunch of young men who just wanted to draw a steady pay check. There's nothing in it for them without an American Power Structure in the country.
Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by nradov on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:15AM (#28169117)
ANA soldiers often didn't even receive steady pay. Their corrupt officers stole it.
Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by hasperdi on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:05AM (#28168982)
Here's a very good explanation of why...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ab9zK8yT4_Y

Basically Afghanistan is very mountainous and Taliban can just cross the border easily into Pakistan

Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by hourislate on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:00AM (#28168935)
>Because the only conclusion I have with this whole mess is that Afgans do not want to resist the Taliban.

This...

Re:U.S. Asks Taliban to Spare Its Embassy in Coming Fight fo... by Ennis on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:08AM (#28169019)
The answers about the population not having the will to fight miss the point completely and are irrelevant and propagate racist views. Afghanistan has a pre-existing system of tribal relationships that are constantly dynamic. The Taliban are effective because they negotiated a path with the pre-existing power structures. The central government is only one player of many.

CBC wrote a brief article on this recently: https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/taliban-revival-aug13-1.613...