News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Little kids burn so much energy, they’re like a different... by watwut on Friday August 13, 2021 @05:36AM (#28167063)
> Without more details if be inclined to blame "almost identical" as the culprit (not an expert):

Why? I mean, why do people find the idea of older people needing different diet due to body changes related to age so unbelievable? There are many changes related to age - how quickly injuries heal, how quickly you recover from something physical or tiring, how much or well you sleep. Your heartrate is slowly changing with age too.

Why would it be shocking that these has also impact on how food affects your look?

> To counteract the aforementioned 10lbs/yr you'd have to walk an extra ~20 minutes per day.

That is not how this works tho. The effect of exercise is not just in how many calories you theoretically spent running/walking exactly same distance. Your body adjusts to exercising way more - including on metabolism and body temperature. It has impact on how body works overall including on hunger - depending on exercise it can go both toward eating less or eating more. It has impact on how many muscles you have, how much energy you burn while building those muscles etc.

Experience of "I stopped exercising and keep eating the same, I gained a lot of weight" is not rare.

Re:Little kids burn so much energy, they’re like a different... by hansvm on Friday August 13, 2021 @11:42AM (#28170370)
> Why?

Because it's much more likely that they're one of the <nearly everyone> who can't estimate calories in/out well than that they're an outlier with a significant metabolic drop in some small number of years, especially given that small misestimations are large enough to yield the observed behavior. Maybe there's something else going on, but "without more details" it wouldn't be the first place I'd look.

> older people needing different diet

Absolutely! I hope nobody took away opposing statements to that from what I said. The double whammy of needing fewer calories and being less equipped to absorb vitamins and whatnot necessitates a significant change in diet with age. I was only commenting on this one person's experience aging just a few years in the middle of their life.

> walking

> That is not how this works tho.

Especially for walking, that's exactly how it works. Walking builds negligible muscle mass, and everything else you've mentioned (aside from perhaps impacts on hunger), adds up to well under a 5% error in calorie estimates -- well under the noise floor from applying a general purpose calorie estimate to any one specific person.

Re:Little kids burn so much energy, they’re like a different... by bojan on Friday August 13, 2021 @07:04AM (#28167538)
> Experience of "I stopped exercising and keep eating the same, I gained a lot of weight" is not rare.

It's not rare because calories add up immensely quickly. Say that you were burning 200 kcal per day exercising - and that is a low estimate. If you keep eating the same, you end up keeping 6000 kcal per month more - that translates to 1.7 lbs of body weight - per month. So, 20 lbs in the first year!

Re:Little kids burn so much energy, they’re like a different... by watwut on Friday August 13, 2021 @08:19AM (#28167991)
So the claim is, that simultaneously: 1.) when you stop exercising, it does a lot for weight. 2.) If you start exercising, it does nothing for weight loss.
Re:Little kids burn so much energy, they’re like a different... by quantum_magpie on Friday August 13, 2021 @11:20AM (#28170000)
>1.) when you stop exercising, it does a lot for weight.

Yes, if you also don't downsize your meals at the same time. Which a lot of people don't.

>2.) If you start exercising, it does nothing for weight loss.

Yes, if you increase your food intake because you feel more hungry, which a lot of people do. If you keep eating the same -- then it of course has a noticeable effect.

For exercise to matter in your weight loss, you have to always keep in mind your food intake. It is still very beneficial and should not be ignored!