Re:The bug which lost more than $600M in various cryptocurre...
by nybble41 on Thursday August 12, 2021 @04:13PM
(#28160875)
Irreversibility in the core protocol is a feature, and a necessary one at that.
If you start with irreversible payments and you need payments to be reversible with some kind of review/appeal process you can add reversibility through escrow. The classic arrangement is a 2-of-3 multi-key system where the payment is made to an escrow address where it can be either finalized or refunded only when at least two key holders concur; the third key, held by a neutral third party, is used to settle disputes when the payer and payee cannot come to an agreement on their own.
There are, however, situation were reversible payments are a liability, and there is no way to build an irreversible payment system on top of a reversible one. For example, you can't build a reliable escrow system on top of reversible payments since the payer can trivially circumvent the escrow by unilaterally revoking their payment to the escrow account.
If you start with irreversible payments and you need payments to be reversible with some kind of review/appeal process you can add reversibility through escrow. The classic arrangement is a 2-of-3 multi-key system where the payment is made to an escrow address where it can be either finalized or refunded only when at least two key holders concur; the third key, held by a neutral third party, is used to settle disputes when the payer and payee cannot come to an agreement on their own.
There are, however, situation were reversible payments are a liability, and there is no way to build an irreversible payment system on top of a reversible one. For example, you can't build a reliable escrow system on top of reversible payments since the payer can trivially circumvent the escrow by unilaterally revoking their payment to the escrow account.