News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by baddox on Thursday July 28, 2011 @03:26AM (#2815777)
Slightly similar to this: I recently jailbroke my iPad 2 and installed a cracked application through installous. When you do that, legitimate updates to your cracked applications appear in the app store. Somehow, through some sort of bug, I was actually charged for the app when I accidentally clicked "update all" in the app store. It never asked me for my password (possibly because I had input it recently enough) or asked for a confirmation on the purchase. I didn't even notice it had been purchased until the iTunes receipt came in my email the next day.
Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by Haplo on Thursday July 28, 2011 @03:55AM (#2815826)
So they actually made you pay for a paid app that is installed on your iPad and that you updated through their system. Big deal!

That's hardly a bug of Apple, in my opinion. Installous should be hiding the cracked applications better, it's their bug. Maybe ask for a refund for Installous?

Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by baddox on Thursday July 28, 2011 @02:11PM (#2818125)
The bug is that it didn't ask me to confirm before putting a charge on my account. Normally, if you try to update an app that hasn't been purchased on your account, it will give an error that the discounted price is not available on your account because you haven't purchased the app.

This is most certainly not a big in Installous. Have you used Installous? All it is is a collection of links to cracked .ipa's that people upload to free file-sharing sites.

Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by danieldk on Thursday July 28, 2011 @04:27AM (#2815886)
So, they made you pay for what you should have paid for in the first place. This may be a bug, but I'd rather say karma ;).
Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by baddox on Thursday July 28, 2011 @02:20PM (#2818177)
That's a rather cavalier response when a major company like Apple, which I've trusted with my credit card information, has a bug in their software which can cause unsolicited charges to be made.

The app was only $5, and it's decent enough that I might have used it frequently (in which case I would have bought it anyway). That's not my point. The point is the bug (or at best, the "unexpected behavior") exists and involves actual money. I disagree with these commenters that are justifying this bug simply because it was revealed due to piracy.

Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by gary4gar on Thursday July 28, 2011 @04:00AM (#2815839)
Piracy is not justification.You should not pirate apps in first place. you are breaking law here.

Now since you were using the app & enjoying all its benefits -- its developers are full rights to get paid for their labour & hard work.

Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by baddox on Thursday July 28, 2011 @02:06PM (#2818102)
That's bogus. "Piracy is not justification" doesn't make any sense. What am I trying to justify? I was pointing out a clear bug in the app store: under no circumstances should an unsolicited and unconfirmed charge appear on my account.

My pirating an app does not give Apple the right to charge my account without asking me. Apple's the one that I trusted my credit card info with, and it's their responsibility to not put any unexpected and unsolicited charges on it. I'm not even trying to justify piracy or say it's okay.

Regardless of your opinion on piracy, I'm surprised by this sentiment. Are you and the other commenters suggesting that any time you pirate any software or media, it's justifiable for some third party to charge your account for the price of that item? If I download a torrent of thousands of iPhone apps, should I immediately be charged thousands of dollars, whether or not I even use the apps?

Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by jamaicahest on Thursday July 28, 2011 @07:00AM (#2816184)
So because he stole the app, the developer is allowed to steal money from him? What kind of logic is that?
Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by jeffool on Thursday July 28, 2011 @09:04AM (#2816532)
The developer didn't steal anything. At most, Apple did. But there's probably wording in the agreement about services for payment and Apple taking the payment. Their reasoning likely being he took the service, so they took the money.

Legal? Probably not, but he has no recourse. But it reminds me of when people call the cops and say "arrest that person; they stole my drugs!"

Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by baddox on Thursday July 28, 2011 @02:15PM (#2818154)
I'm not demanding recourse, and I'm not even saying that I am justified in pirating an app. However, I often pirate apps to try them, and the vast majority that I try are terrible, and I uninstall them almost immediately. Therefore, legality aside, I'm not ethically concerned that I'm "stealing" potential revenue from the app developer if I only use their app for 5 minutes.

My point is, this was definitely a bug in the app store, because before any charge there should be a clear modal confirmation dialog (and there normally is).

Re:PayPal User Charged $4,000 for Mac OS X Lion Download by jeffool on Thursday July 28, 2011 @03:42PM (#2818564)
Honestly I've got no problem with what you did. I'm just saying that they probably covered themselves in the legalese.

For instance, my cable company recently shut off my Internet due to excessive DMCA complaints. They told me they had a "four strike" policy. They cut me after three. I could threaten a lawsuit, even if it would be silly, but that would potentially open me up for other legal attacks, so I'm forced to walk away.

So all I'm saying is that they got you in a tight spot, and they've probably paid enough lawyers to make sure they're covered. Their hardware detected software, so they charged you for it. I find it hard to imagine they haven't written it up to cover themselves.