This is absolutely not true. There’s plenty of risk buying expensive goods online, lots of problematic merchants. I don’t understand why merchants are inherently more trustworthy than customers?
The merchant has much less to go on. There aren't review websites detailing the reputation and history of every random buyer that enters a credit card onto your website.
What does that mean?
The phrase "high resale value merchandise" sounds like it refers to the stuff that, in physical stores, is kept in a locked case so you have to ask someone to open it.
But that stuff is readily available online, isn't it?
I assume that most chargebacks happen for purchases made with stolen credit cards. So the chargeback just returns the money to the rightful owner.
If the consumer used bitcoin, and someone stole their credentials to buy something, then they would have no way to get their money back.
Yes, they become possible at the cost of putting the counterparty risk onto the consumer, but that's better than the sale being entirely non-viable.
Merchants are in a much better position to price this in than consumers. Merchants structurally execute a lot more transactions within a market vertical than consumers ever do.
If the merchant can't do that, because deals are simply too high value or aren't frequent enough, then insurance companies or intermediaries (e.g. payment processors) can pool risk across merchants, using actuarial techniques to assign a price to the insurance. For example, professional indemnity insurance for property transactions.
To counteract this negative feedback loop, assuming the increased prices don't drive away all of your real customers, you can spend the increase on transaction analysis, and turn away customers based on their likelihood of fraud, so you've added inefficiency into the system to help deal with a criminal element, and also likely turned away real sales due to false positives in your analysis.
It's no surprise that these types of merchants are looking for a disruptive technology to remove this inefficiency. Doing so would allow them to charge less and outcompete as well as capture the entire market of people marked as false positives by other merchants.
Especially when the risk of customers committing fraud is incredibly low. Why would you start with an assumption that this is something so rampant it needs to be solved in a way that harms literally all honest customers?
If you think fraud rates are extremely low, you've never tried to sell $2,000 electronics online as a boutique electronics store.
Bitcoin was the only option.
Regardless, how does Bitcoin solve this? There’s a lot of illegitimate users of crypto, how are you solving fraud with irreversible transactions?
It's difficult to find sources, but generally speaking you are going to go 'on warning' at around 1.5% and if you go too much over 2% chargeback rate you just get dropped by the credit card company as a customer. Credit card companies don't like dealing with high fraud customers and won't support you.
https://chargeback.com/average-chargeback-rates-how-does-you... https://chargebacks911.com/chargeback-rate/
Bitcoin helps in two ways. The first is that it gives you a way to accept money at all. As stated above, if your chargeback rate is above 2% for any extended period of time, all of your payment processors - including your banks - are going to drop you as a customer. You may be willing to pay 5% overheads for a higher chargeback rate, but your credit card company doesn't want that as a statistic and they just won't support you.
The other way Bitcoin helps is that once your wallet (use BTCPay) says "2 confirmations" you've got a 99.97% guarantee that the money is yours and won't be reverted. And that's true whether you are receiving $2,000 or $2,000,000. Regardless of whether that money came from "an illegitimate user", you as the merchant can be confident shipping hardware out because you know that the payment is not going to be clawed back.
A strong example of where the irreversibility of crypto is very useful is in the online sale of expensive electronic goods. Especially for things like speakers, TVs, and projectors, fraud rates are extremely high and boutique shops struggle to effectively support online customers, because such a large percentage of their sales get chargebacks after they've shipped the goods.
If you accept crypto, you have a 100% guarantee that when the money has hit your wallet, the money is good and will stay in your wallet. You don't need to deal with an anti-fraud firm, you don't need to check whether this person is trying to have the goods shipped to a sketchy country, and you don't need to fear that your $6,000 item is going to sail away from you without payment.
Yes, this means that the consumer has to fully trust the merchant, but in the case of online sales, the merchant is the known quantity with a reputation. Every consumer is a random, unknown person to the merchant and so it's much harder (and therefore more expensive) for the merchant to establish trustworthyness.