Re:Charlie's Diary: Why I Hate Star Trek (2009)
by fuball63 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @03:29PM
(#28146575)
I've read this before, and while I agree that there are tropes, like the techbabble mentioned in the article as well as creating suspense with arbitrary timelines ("we have a routine task BUT the core will explode in 30 minutes"), I think the fact that the specific tech is irrelevant is one of the greatest strengths of Star Trek.
The Star Trek universe is one where people live in a post-scarcity, post-war, and heavily automated earth and are free to pursue creative or explorative endeavors. The technology in the show is designed to be seamless; the computer responds to voice commands, doors open on their own, food is ordered from a machine. It is intentional that, in Star Trek, there aren't people huddled in front of a screen all day typing on a keyboard.
The reason for that is because a show that would be hyper focused on how tech works would be incredibly boring. And, at least in my opinion, it isn't important. The author says the characters "don't tell us anything interesting about the human condition under science fictional circumstances", but that isn't true. Many episodes revolve around what it means to be human and our role in the universe on a wider philosophical context. Whether the warp drive can realistically be snapped to warp 11 doesn't affect that at all.
To give a real world example, consider the Snowden revelations. I don't know the specifics on how the NSA algorithm worked, or what storage devices they used, or if it is possible to perform a certain operation on it. It isn't interesting nor does it speak to realities of a post 9/11 America. What is interesting are questions on the balance between privacy and security, the underwhelming public concern, and the lack of transparency in a government body. I feel like Star Trek would have covered those stories, techbabble or not.
Re:Charlie's Diary: Why I Hate Star Trek (2009)
by CRConrad on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:18AM
(#28155905)
> The Star Trek universe is one where people live in a post-scarcity, post-war, and heavily automated earth and are free to pursue creative or explorative endeavors.
Or, as Stross mentions in the blog post, they're in (some future equivalent of) the military: In stead of on a space ship travelling the universe, they could be on an 18th-century HMS Enterprise, criss-crossing the seven seas, encountering a new population of exotic islanders each episode, in stead of aliens. Bit more scarcity on those, if they stayed out too long and the vats of beef ran out or went too spoiled, but similar otherwise: Everybody wears a uniform, doesn't worry about money (you'll spend your meager coin / automatically-accumulated Credit Units when you get back home to Blighty / Mars), and implicitly cares about the same mission. Heck, replace Klingons and whatever the other ones were called with Frogs and Yanks, and you have the constant enemy that pops in every other episode.
Re:Charlie's Diary: Why I Hate Star Trek (2009)
by d0mine on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @04:15PM
(#28147157)
Nice argument. Unrelated: what would you say about idea that Snowden never stopped working for NSA: it was inevitable that some truth will come out about the scale of surveillance and Snowden mission is to expose the info on NSA terms (intentional leak).
Re:Charlie's Diary: Why I Hate Star Trek (2009)
by foxyv on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @04:13PM
(#28147131)
Star Trek is certainly very limited. There is a reason that reboots have been a bit lacking. The things that made Star Trek great weren't the technology and action so much as the philosophy and how people reacted to it. For instance: the rights of androids, teleportation, non-human intelligence, religion, animal rights, racism, xenophobia, and environmentalism.
Star Trek took modern issues and juxtaposed them against an advanced society without the pressures that made them so pressing. Racism between humans seems ridiculous in the face of wars that could destroy or subjugate our entire species and unlimited resources. Taking care of a planet makes so much sense when you have nearly unlimited clean energy and the ability to destroy a solar system in a moment. Killing animals for meat seems barbaric when you can fabricate perfect facsimiles of meat without killing.
Star Trek technology inspired dreams of a better society. Not just better technology.
Re:Charlie's Diary: Why I Hate Star Trek (2009)
by krapp on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @05:50PM
(#28148257)
Star Trek's utopian vision feels cheap and unearned. They paper over the difficulty of justifying their "post-scarcity" philosophy by ignoring basic human nature and having magitech wish-granting black boxes and free energy. There's nothing aspirational about that, by definition we can't get there from here.
It doesn't help that, as the franchise went on, humanity became basically one of the most powerful species in the galaxy. They go from the Borg presenting an existential threat to the entire Federation with a single cube to Janeway one-shotting them. DS9 and the Dominion Arc at least put humanity on its back footing, but for the most part, humans are at the top of the food chain.
I prefer the way B5 portrays similar themes - humanity has a definite presence in galactic affairs, but as a newcomer surrounded by civilizations far older and more powerful, and more adept at the dark arts of war and politics. There are no free lunches, no replicators, no teleporters. Humanity has to struggle, sometimes red in tooth and claw, to climb every rung of the ladder from ape to angel. Optimism and unity win out not because humanity has evolved beyond its base nature, but as a result of the constant struggle against that nature.
Re:Charlie's Diary: Why I Hate Star Trek (2009)
by foxyv on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:34AM
(#28156842)
> Star Trek's utopian vision feels cheap and unearned.
Yeah, this is pretty much a perfect description of later seasons. I think people instantly picked up on this and checked out. When they ended Voyager like that it was a kick in the teeth.
The Star Trek universe is one where people live in a post-scarcity, post-war, and heavily automated earth and are free to pursue creative or explorative endeavors. The technology in the show is designed to be seamless; the computer responds to voice commands, doors open on their own, food is ordered from a machine. It is intentional that, in Star Trek, there aren't people huddled in front of a screen all day typing on a keyboard.
The reason for that is because a show that would be hyper focused on how tech works would be incredibly boring. And, at least in my opinion, it isn't important. The author says the characters "don't tell us anything interesting about the human condition under science fictional circumstances", but that isn't true. Many episodes revolve around what it means to be human and our role in the universe on a wider philosophical context. Whether the warp drive can realistically be snapped to warp 11 doesn't affect that at all.
To give a real world example, consider the Snowden revelations. I don't know the specifics on how the NSA algorithm worked, or what storage devices they used, or if it is possible to perform a certain operation on it. It isn't interesting nor does it speak to realities of a post 9/11 America. What is interesting are questions on the balance between privacy and security, the underwhelming public concern, and the lack of transparency in a government body. I feel like Star Trek would have covered those stories, techbabble or not.
Or, as Stross mentions in the blog post, they're in (some future equivalent of) the military: In stead of on a space ship travelling the universe, they could be on an 18th-century HMS Enterprise, criss-crossing the seven seas, encountering a new population of exotic islanders each episode, in stead of aliens. Bit more scarcity on those, if they stayed out too long and the vats of beef ran out or went too spoiled, but similar otherwise: Everybody wears a uniform, doesn't worry about money (you'll spend your meager coin / automatically-accumulated Credit Units when you get back home to Blighty / Mars), and implicitly cares about the same mission. Heck, replace Klingons and whatever the other ones were called with Frogs and Yanks, and you have the constant enemy that pops in every other episode.
It's basically a Space-Opera-slash-Space-Western.
Star Trek took modern issues and juxtaposed them against an advanced society without the pressures that made them so pressing. Racism between humans seems ridiculous in the face of wars that could destroy or subjugate our entire species and unlimited resources. Taking care of a planet makes so much sense when you have nearly unlimited clean energy and the ability to destroy a solar system in a moment. Killing animals for meat seems barbaric when you can fabricate perfect facsimiles of meat without killing.
Star Trek technology inspired dreams of a better society. Not just better technology.
It doesn't help that, as the franchise went on, humanity became basically one of the most powerful species in the galaxy. They go from the Borg presenting an existential threat to the entire Federation with a single cube to Janeway one-shotting them. DS9 and the Dominion Arc at least put humanity on its back footing, but for the most part, humans are at the top of the food chain.
I prefer the way B5 portrays similar themes - humanity has a definite presence in galactic affairs, but as a newcomer surrounded by civilizations far older and more powerful, and more adept at the dark arts of war and politics. There are no free lunches, no replicators, no teleporters. Humanity has to struggle, sometimes red in tooth and claw, to climb every rung of the ladder from ape to angel. Optimism and unity win out not because humanity has evolved beyond its base nature, but as a result of the constant struggle against that nature.
Yeah, this is pretty much a perfect description of later seasons. I think people instantly picked up on this and checked out. When they ended Voyager like that it was a kick in the teeth.