News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:So you want to write a GUI framework by capableweb on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @01:48PM (#28145253)
> And a downside for the user as the GUI will probably not be consistent with its OS

Depends on what kind of "user". Many professionals that spend their day in software like the Autodesk suite of applications, Music production, Animation or other creative endeavors expect consistent GUI across OSes when using the same tool, not consistent GUIs within the specific OS for all tools.

Re:So you want to write a GUI framework by kaba0 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @04:17PM (#28147175)
And interestingly none are written with web technologies —- sufficiently complex GUIs are no good fit for that.
Re:So you want to write a GUI framework by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @03:32PM (#28146606)
How many of those users ever use more than one OS?
Re:So you want to write a GUI framework by kbenson on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @03:56PM (#28146928)
How many of them might be following directions from someone or giving directions to someone on a different OS?

How often we use something and what type of things we're doing on it (work, play, etc) probably greatly affect how we think about this. I expect my tools to work the same no matter where I use them. For things I don't rely on to get essential work done, I care less, on a sliding scale.

Re:So you want to write a GUI framework by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @06:00PM (#28148366)
I expect my tools to work well too, that's why they're almost never web-based.
Re:So you want to write a GUI framework by kbenson on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @06:30PM (#28148699)
Sure, but there's a difference between web-based and built using web technologies. Whatever other faults electron apps have, they're fairly consistent across operating systems. For a tool (like a chat client) that's very appealing. It's all that other things that seem to be endemic to electron apps (high resource usage, large size) that are the problem. Theoretically if you make a webapp that works fine on Safari Edge and Chrome you could use the OS provided webviews on iOS, MacOS, Android and Windows (and Electron on other platforms I guess) to ship local equivalents that are less problematic at the expense of more engineering work (or maybe just a leaner meaner electron competitor).