You can write insurance for anything, if you're willing to pay enough premium. I can't imagine this premium would be that exorbitant for Airbnb to pay for it's users, just as Getaround does.
In fact they have an even better guarantee, since they know (ideally...) exactly who the perpetrator was. They're not giving you the money to replace your stuff, they're lending it to you until they can recover it from the criminal. If the person who you claim did the damage claims they didn't, that's a problem they have with you, not with Airbnb.
There's also the fact that insurance companies are subject to many laws and regulations that other businesses are not.
Surely that should already be a primary focus of theirs.
Are they going to require faxing in photocopies of ID? Run credit checks? All this would do is to verify that a person with this information exists. This wouldn't stop a bad guy from using someone else's identification to register, and none of this addresses whether the renter has the legal right to rent the property.
And, once they are that deep in the process, if Airbnb is making any representations to their customers about this kind of vetting, then they are exposing themselves to liability if something goes wrong.
Right now, they are content to verify that the customer and landlord have valid credit cards / bank accounts, and that's that.
Fraud is a problem with all insurance policies. Deductibles and investigations go a long way to curtail it.
They can also set the premium high enough to cover the costs and get to claim that it's available if the homeowner chooses, even though most won't do to the high price. It's a feature that would make them stand out among their ever growing competitors.
can UberCab happen here, ie. some zealous DA would come down on AirBnB itself and/or subpoena the records of people renting out?
http://www.nyc.gov/html/dof/html/business/business_tax_hotel...
So yes, at some point I'd say it is likely that AirBnb's records are going to be used against their customers. Some of AirBnb's customers aren't breaking the law, but some are.
Of course, the odds that the criminal has anything left to take are low...
And yet your analysis of this particular case is spot-on. They stand to get CRUSHED by this story.
Damned if they do, and damned if they don't.