News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by marcusverus on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:14AM (#28141584)
> the government needs to make voting for federal elections compulsory in order to get people to take a stance / have an opinion (yes, you will get a fine if you don’t vote!)

This seems like such a bad idea. Ideally, the democratic process taps ‘the wisdom of crowds’ and allows a society to make reasonable decisions. But all human beings are not capable of contributing to good decision making. Roughly the 15% of people have IQs below 85, making them effectively mentally retarded. And beyond that, a huge number of people are grossly uninformed about contemporary political issues, history, science, etc. The best contribution that some folks can make to the democratic process is not participating in the democratic process.

Moreover, if you force the unintelligent and uninformed to vote, you’re empowering the media to run the country. When someone’s politics are uninformed by firmly held principals and a solid understanding of history and current events, they will be more susceptible to be steered by biased media.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by gonzo41 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:51AM (#28141929)
I'm Australian. Respectfully, you're totally wrong.

Government should be for everyone. Parties should have a platform that is for a majority. For the most part, Australia has populist fairly centrist small c conservative governments.

It's getting bad at the moment here mostly because the current governing party is past due for it's turn on the opposition benches. And it also seems that everyone's having a go at being corrupt at the moment. Hopefully we get ontop of that.

Anyway, folk with low IQ's making bad choices isn't really a problem. We have optional preferential voting (rank choice), it's hard enough to make an informed decision above or below the line each time and I do research!

Most of the uniformed, just vote along family lines.

Anyway, everyone has a right to vote and a duty in some respect. Making it harder for some, by making it opt in, will lead to more problems then having disengaged voters participating in haphazard ways.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by marcusverus on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @05:01PM (#28147665)
> Anyway, folk with low IQ's making bad choices isn't really a problem.

You don't seek out the advice of the mentally retarded when making personal decisions. Why would you do so when determining how to run your society?

> Most of the uniformed, just vote along family lines.

The point of a democratic elections is to get the considered input of the population. People who 'just vote along family lines' are noise in the signal. If they want to, then fine. But why would you force them to contribute their arbitrary, uninformed opinions?

> Anyway, everyone has a right to vote and a duty in some respect.

Of course they do.

> Making it harder for some, by making it opt in, will lead to more problems then having disengaged voters participating in haphazard ways.

This is nonsense. Forcing older kids to go to school doesn't result in more engaged school-kids, it results in rooms full of angry, disengaged kids who cause problems for the people who want to be there. Similarly, forcing people to vote just adds a bunch of random votes to the pile.

Democracy is a great thing. But democracy doesn't work because more human hands touching ballots makes for better government--it works because you can get good advice by asking the input of a large number of responsible, conscientious people.

We know that the least educated among us are the least likely to vote. We also know that IQ predicts academic achievement. So why would you go out of your way to increase the proportion of Prec

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by c_o_n_v_e_x on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:17AM (#28142260)
Re: voting, it's not a "right" if it's compulsory. It's an obligation.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by otikik on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:45AM (#28143468)
It's easy to forget that every right comes with obligation.

Say you have the right to own property. That comes with the obligation to respect other people's property. And so on.

When a right comes obligations it isn't a right. It's a privilege. That's the stuff kings used to have (and still have, in some places).

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwaheyy on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @12:06PM (#28143789)
Technically, you have the right not to vote in Australia, but you must still show up and collect a ballot paper. You can leave it blank, or scribble anything on it.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by strken on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:39AM (#28143354)
What's the practical meaningful difference between exercising your right to not vote, vs fulfilling your obligation to vote by showing up to the polling place and drawing dicks on the ballot paper?

Pretend you're an Australian and have a long tradition of fining people minor sums of money for not showing up. Why would you change to non-compulsory voting?

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by partomniscient on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:47AM (#28143487)
Your scenario also needs to account for free sausage sandwiches. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_sausage

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by gonzo41 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:23AM (#28142354)
it's a pretty low impost obligation. But I'd refer to it as a minor duty to the community.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by swader999 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:34AM (#28143269)
Not voting though is a form of protest in many cases. I suppose though even if it is compulsory you could show up and spoil your ballot. I'd be fine with that.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by gonzo41 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:43AM (#28143418)
Many do just that.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by AdrianB1 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @01:20PM (#28144868)
It is not clear from your comment if you really believe the village idiot should vote; that is 15% of the population or even more, in some cases. Having the right to vote ... still in doubt, but expecting their participation to decision making - hell no. It is just about realism and competence, when you go to a doctor's office for a consultation you ask for the competent doctor to respond or you ask everyone in the building to vote your diagnostic? A significant part of the population is not competent enough to vote.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by whatshisface on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:58AM (#28142806)
>Roughly the 15% of people have IQs below 85, making them effectively mentally retarded. And beyond that, a huge number of people are grossly uninformed about contemporary political issues, history, science, etc. The best contribution that some folks can make to the democratic process is not participating in the democratic process.

You're thinking of the role of democracy as a way to solve problems, but it also plays a role in fairly allocating resources between sectors of society. The IQ < 85 demographic might not seem valuable to the IQ > 115 demographic, but in fact that is why they need to vote, to counterbalance the self-interest of the IQ > 115 demographic. Likewise, PhDs in political science might be prone to think that highschool dropouts are not valuable contributors, but that is exactly why highschool dropouts need to vote - to counterbalance the will of the political science PhDs to support policies that only help PhDs.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jacobr1 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @12:37PM (#28144281)
The paternalistic argument is that the low-IQ voters will be misled, and vote _against_ their own interests. That they just will vote for whatever higher-IQ group can best market to them, and will get a basket of outcomes that is, at best, indifferent to their specific needs. This argument is very dismissive the agency of these individuals.

I would argue that largely happens today, but not on the basis of IQ. Large chunks of western countries believe all sorts of (what I would consider) crazy things. And IQ isn't the driving force of belief here.

None of this is an argument to disenfranchise segments of the populace. But it is also increasingly naive to believe that voters vote on the basis of rational self-interest, and we need to have serious discussions about how to counter the forces that drive that, be it IQ, misinformation, in-group/out-group dynamics and more.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by ubercore on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:39AM (#28141813)
I think your point here would be far stronger without the intelligence argument. I don't want to tell someone they can't vote because they didn't pass an IQ test threshold.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by marcusverus on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @04:47PM (#28147517)
> I don't want to tell someone they can't vote because they didn't pass an IQ test threshold.

You've misunderstood my comment. I'm not saying that we should prevent unintelligent people from voting, I'm saying we shouldn't actively seek out their input by compelling them to vote.

We know that poorly educated people are the least likely to vote, and we know that educational achievement correlates strongly with IQ--so by requiring voting, you will be significantly increasing the proportion of voters who are not intellectually capable of making an informed decision about how we can run a society.

You do not seek out the advice of the least intelligent people you know. Even if, out of a stubborn commitment to egalitarian ideals, you did ask for their advice, you'd be a fool to weight it equally with the people who you hold in high regard. So why the hell would we, as a society, choose to do so by compelling the vote?

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by L_226 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:47AM (#28141885)
You don't need to tell them they can't vote, you just need to tell them there is free beer at the footy on that day /s
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by gonzo41 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:52AM (#28141948)
Well, elections usually happen around the AFL and Rugby finals, so there's a fair bit of drinking happening. So why not vote, get a snag and then get drunk. Seems like a win win for everyone.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by IG_Semmelweiss on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:56AM (#28143652)
Correct.

There is a natural experiment on this. See which countries have compulsory voting and see how they have fared since. The results are not pretty.

On the flipside, the strongest "free" countries, switzerland and USA, have had voluntary parricipation since time immemorial...

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by babesh on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:10AM (#28142949)
Wait till you hear about what the IQ > 130 demographic think of the IQ <= 130 demographic and what the IQ > 140 demographic think of the IQ <= 140 demographic.