News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Father of Cryonics Dies at 92, Frozen in Cryonics Institute by ChuckMcM on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @04:21PM (#2813936)
I've always felt, in a very non-disparaging way, that cryonics filled the need for secular humanists to believe in an afterlife.

An interesting point was brought up in the comments too, which is if we had a bunch of frozen folks from the 1600's and we could unfreeze them and bring them back to life, would that be the right choice?

That is the moral 'nub' which I find fascinating about this stuff (and yes it has been chewed fruitfully by writers before).

So imagine you could bring someone back from the 60's. What would they do today? The most brilliant computer designer would probably de-thaw believing that the IBM 360 with its channel architecture was the coolest thing. Show them the multi-issue pipeline of a modern microprocessor with register coloring, branch prediction, and early instruction retirement and their brain would explode.

When you are young the wonder of a new thing gives you the energy to read about how it works, when you're older (or just in a hurry) having to spend time reading the manual or 'fiddling with' a tool to understand it enough to use it is bothersome. Can you imagine waking up and everything you know is expected to be known by teens ? All your hard earned wisdom is worthless?

Since we're speculating there are things we can't really know but we can wonder about.

So what will be the economic status of these people once thawed? It could be 'good' in a post singularity world where anything can be made for 'free', or it could be 'bad' where thawed people are treated like the property of the person who paid to thaw them.

I would hate to find myself waking up, fuzzily, and have an insistent voice saying, "you've been reanimated by xyzcorp, click 'yes' to agree to their terms for paying off your debt to them, or 'no thankyou' to be re-frozen."

Re:Father of Cryonics Dies at 92, Frozen in Cryonics Institute by mmaro on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @04:55PM (#2814050)
Well, as long as we're considering all sorts of hypothetical scenarios, consider this one:

1. You die in a year or two from terminal illness or an accident.

2. You purchased a life insurance policy when you were healthy, so cryonics is very cheap.

3. Unforeseen advances in AI/nanotech/medicine allow you to be revived in just 15-20 years.

4. You are back from the dead and find subsistence (let alone wealth) in the near future superior to your old life.

Re:Father of Cryonics Dies at 92, Frozen in Cryonics Institute by barry-cotter on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:46PM (#2814333)
In general I prefer being alive to being dead. It seems extremely likely that if we're capable of reanimating people who were dead we will be able to give them youthful bodies again. People don't seem to have huge problems with voluntarily supporting expensive invalids (children) for decades if it's a free choice. By analogy with asylum seekers immigrating to the first world I expect that people with radically lower human capital in their new environment normally adjust to their new lives and are relatively happy with them (otherwise they could go home or kill themselves)

So; assuming technology sufficient for reanimation allows for rejuvenation I expect that people would very slowly adjust to their new surroundings (unless the differences between societies are larger than between Hmong hill tribesmen who had never seen a tv and 1960's America) and be generally happy with their new surroundings. Given that rejuvenation implies the possibility of eternal youth and health I assert that people could eventually totally integrate with their new society, though not all would. Still, if you're back at peak mental and physical fitness and you have more than 10 years to adapt to the culture and acquire education/human capital/skills why couldn't it work?

Re:Father of Cryonics Dies at 92, Frozen in Cryonics Institute by drblue on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @08:32PM (#2814874)
> "it could be 'bad' where thawed people are treated like the property of the person who paid to thaw them."

The majority of funding goes into the patient care trust, which is used for upkeep of the patients and (hopefully) eventual revival.

http://www.alcor.org/AboutAlcor/patientcaretrustfund.html

At least with Alcor, your scenario is impossible and I'd be very surprised if CI didn't have an analog.

Re:Father of Cryonics Dies at 92, Frozen in Cryonics Institute by lsparrish on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @08:08PM (#2814821)
"if we had a bunch of frozen folks from the 1600's and we could unfreeze them and bring them back to life, would that be the right choice?"

Kill someone just because they are a bit behind the times? Triage is fine, but we're talking about a chance to save someone healthy and alive when there are plenty of resources.

"So what will be the economic status of these people once thawed?"

Barring drastic economic changes, compound interest from the trust fund should put them in good shape.

Re:Father of Cryonics Dies at 92, Frozen in Cryonics Institute by Symmetry on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:04PM (#2814105)
I think that it would certainly be the right thing to do to bring back anyone, like Ben Franklin, who wanted to be preserved to see what the future would bring. I'd say that we should work to bring back anyone who want to be be brought back, but also not force various sort of life extension on people.
Re:Father of Cryonics Dies at 92, Frozen in Cryonics Institute by abecedarius on Thursday July 28, 2011 @01:40AM (#2815544)
Show them the multi-issue pipeline of a modern microprocessor with register coloring, branch prediction, and early instruction retirement and their brain would explode.

http://www.brouhaha.com/~eric/retrocomputing/ibm/stretch/