News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High number of infosec textbooks almost 100% copied, acco... by _delirium on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @03:24PM (#2813699)
A decent number of the non-self-published ones seem to come from Course Technology PTR, which is moderately respectable. They do have something of a reputation for not being too rigorous or selective, but until now I hadn't thought of them as having a bad reputation, just a bit of a shamelessly commercial one. They rush out large numbers of textbooks on recent technologies, of mixed quality, but some are good. Apparently their reviewing could use some improvement, though.
Re:High number of infosec textbooks almost 100% copied, acco... by keithpeter on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @04:42PM (#2814007)
I think it could!

On a recent contract for writing e-learning materials I had an editor who was herself a subject expert going over the words, references and the actual pedagogic design. Then I had the multimedia team suggesting changes and sequencing the material.

I'd say the original writing was 40% and the response to editing was 60%.

PS have a look at the image they used on the top of the article... I've got an embarrassingly large number of those books...

Re:High number of infosec textbooks almost 100% copied, acco... by _delirium on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @04:56PM (#2814055)
Hmm, interesting. That level of detail is fairly uncommon for academic publishing from what I know, though I am not too experienced myself. When someone like MIT Press publishes a book, the way I've heard the process described is that three external academic reviewers will give high-level feedback and make publish/don't-publish recommendations, and then one MIT Press editor not necessarily expert in the area will do layout/stylistic/copy/flow editing. But partly that's because they have a line to walk between providing real editing and quality control, but also providing a not-too-filtered platform for authors to put out their own views.

I would hope that extensive plagiarism would be caught by one of the academic reviewers, though.

Though with Course PTR it's probably more just lack of per-book resources. When you're rushing to get out a book that amounts to a manual for XNA 3.1, and you put out dozens of those books a year, there's only so much detailed editing you can give it.