News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by Syonyk on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @06:47PM (#28135735)
Facebook has a problem with misinformation - it's just that their problem isn't the same as what people assume their problem is.

"Misinformation" tends to be spectacularly engaging content - which is quite profitable.

People upset about misinformation on Facebook tend to use Facebook less, which is less profitable.

The ideal solution for Facebook is that they can show misinformation to people they know will outrage-scroll as a result, while not showing misinformation to people who might be upset about Facebook not really having done much about it.

"Transparency" extensions and such violate this, badly. You might find out what sort of ads Facebook shows your aunt out one side of their site while talking about how they're combatting misinformation on the other.

They've solved the problem.

Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by cwkoss on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @07:44PM (#28136215)
I wonder if Facebook has a big list of misinformation published by major news organizations that they aren't sure what to do with.

I often see the same people who talk about how dangerous sites like PatriotFreedomEagleNews are in terms of misinformation respond belligerently when shown evidence of similar misinformation coming from CNN or MSNBC. The list of reliably credible news sources is much shorter than most people believe.

Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by jjoonathan on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @08:13PM (#28136415)
They're reacting to the false equivalency you are drawing, not the evidence that CNN or MSNBC spread misinformation, but I doubt I'll be able to change your mind on the matter.
Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by cwkoss on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @08:52PM (#28136654)
What makes the equivalency false?
Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by tshaddox on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @07:04PM (#28135911)
I'm pretty sure that people upset about misinformation on Facebook are upset about misinformation being shown to other people, including people who are pleased (which is to say engaged) by misinformation.
Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by Nevermark on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @07:46PM (#28136238)
Right. And even people who like their own brand of misinformation are not happy about other people enjoying other conflicting brands of misinformation. And this is true whether we are talking about objective misinformation or subjective "misinformation".

And so Facebook is fantastically incentivized to give each person not just what they want, but to leak as little about other people's objectionable/"objectionable" (in your eyes) experiences to you as possible.

For Facebook "cleaning up" means, optimal silo-ing.

Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by tshaddox on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @08:21PM (#28136472)
Yeah, it's easy to imagine that as a pretty natural direction for Facebook. It's already barely "social" in the traditional sense of sharing stuff with your friends (at least for a lot of people, based on my impression). If it's way more engaging to separate each person from whatever vestige of a "real friend" group they still have, and funnel them down whatever rabbit hole they engage with the most (regardless of whether it's a misinformation rabbit hole, although I suspect many would be), then I would certainly expect Facebook to do so.
Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by Enginerrrd on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @07:02PM (#28135893)
While I wouldn't be surprised at this at all given their track record and incentives, is there any evidence that this is what they're doing?
Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by Syonyk on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @09:07PM (#28136742)
At some point, many years ago, it was reasonable to assume Facebook had something resembling honest intentions.

That has been proven wrong so many times, across such a wide range of topics, that at this point it's reasonable to assume actions by Facebook correspond to "What makes us more money," and any press release about the actions is "How can we spin this in such a way that the most people possible will swallow it and keep using Facebook?"

Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by Enginerrrd on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:35PM (#28171149)
I lean toward your side here, but I still like to seek out confirmation for things I agree with.
Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by prox on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @06:51PM (#28135781)
Is there a name for this skewing?
Re:Facebook Shuts Down Researchers Looking into Misinformation by Syonyk on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @06:54PM (#28135810)
Zucking it up?

I just put it in the category of "What's Good for Facebook is Good for Facebook."