Re:LevelDB Benchmarks
by snewman on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @04:28PM
(#2813958)
I wish they had done a benchmark of mixed reads and writes. LSMs have some nice properties, but read performance in the presence of writes may not be as good as when there are no writes. With no write traffic, you wind up with only a single .sst file, so reads only have to consult that one table.
Re:LevelDB Benchmarks
by thezilch on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @02:12PM
(#2813325)
It'd be interesting to see LevelDB pitted against InnoDB/HandlerSocket and Redis (with eventual diskstore) in the k/v department. Both have a lot more going for them, where the need arises for a higher level or "more structured" access to the same underlying data, offered by MySQL or Redis structures (lists, sets, hashes, etc).
This benchmark seems trustworthy because they have lots of benchmarks where LevelDB performs much worse than the competition (writing large objects; random reads with large caches)
Re:LevelDB Benchmarks
by sirrice on Friday July 29, 2011 @03:11PM
(#2823332)
It would be nice to see longer running experimentsto see how a) long term usage (compaction in LSM trees) and b) disk interactions (benefits of compression) impact performance.
For example, in the large values experiment, the experiment executes 1000 writes. However if the results report LevelDB as 1060 ops/sec. Assuming op == write, then the experiment ran for all of 1 second. This shows great instantaneous performance, but what if it kept running?
Additionally, it appears that no-compression is the way to go, which makes sense for small values and an in-memory experiment, but is that the case when disk comes into play?
Re:LevelDB Benchmarks
by andytwigg on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @04:42PM
(#2870093)
I've read most of the messages on this list with interest. I've done some benchmarking on LevelDB with billions of entries, and on commodity flash SSDs, and thought that summarising it might be of interest to folks on this list:
Re:LevelDB Benchmarks
by ryanpetrich on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:15PM
(#2814168)
The synchronous writes benchmark is suspect--on a 7200rpm disk it seems impossible to get 2,400 dependent transactions (or even sqlite's 430) with a full disk sync. Is this due to ext3's relaxed notion of fsync?
Re:LevelDB Benchmarks
by MichaelGG on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:55PM
(#2814371)
Well look how SQLite does write ahead logging (assuming I understand it). Transactions can go into the log and commit, without modifying the original data. Now and then, it can "checkpoint" to move those logged transactions into the database. This way, transactions are mainly sequential writes, with a bit of maintenance now and then.
I've used a similar approach for a constant database. The transaction log goes to disk, but also stays in memory. Scanning it linearly isn't that slow. When it grows too large, the log is converted into a disk-optimized format, which is a rather quick process. This way, it can take tons of writes, service reads acceptably, while still being able to store much more data than RAM and offering fast access to on-disk data.
Re:LevelDB Benchmarks
by ryanpetrich on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:16PM
(#2814466)
I understand that to be the case when not using synchronous. The point of synchronous full is that sqlite should only consider a transaction committed when it is fully flushed to disk. Assuming a 7200rpm disk that isn't lying to you, at most 120 dependent transactions a second should be even possible.
(this should apply equally to other databases that have a similar option)
Re:LevelDB Benchmarks
by ryanpetrich on Thursday July 28, 2011 @07:59PM
(#2819554)
I hadn't thought of that. If the disk can perform some localized remapping, it's possible to get sequential fsynced writes to exceed the rotation speed.
" Is this due to ext3's relaxed notion of fsync?" -- I believe so, especially given the warning about ext4 at the bottom.
>The preceding numbers are for an ext3 file system. Synchronous writes are much slower under ext4 (LevelDB drops to ~34 writes / second, TreeDB drops to ~5 writes / second; SQLite3 drops to ~24 writes / second) due to ext4's different handling of fsync / msync calls. Even LevelDB's asynchronous write performance drops somewhat since it spreads its storage across multiple files and issues fsync calls when switching to a new file.
Still, good to have some numbers.
So this is basically a comparison between those, right?
Does a LSM offer ordered access or do you lose that feature and gain a bit of speed?
For example, in the large values experiment, the experiment executes 1000 writes. However if the results report LevelDB as 1060 ops/sec. Assuming op == write, then the experiment ran for all of 1 second. This shows great instantaneous performance, but what if it kept running?
Additionally, it appears that no-compression is the way to go, which makes sense for small values and an in-memory experiment, but is that the case when disk comes into play?
http://www.acunu.com/blogs/andy-twigg/benchmarking-leveldb/
Comments most welcome.
-Andy
-- CTO, Acunu Inc. www.acunu.com | http://www.cs.ox.ac.uk/people/andy.twigg/
I've used a similar approach for a constant database. The transaction log goes to disk, but also stays in memory. Scanning it linearly isn't that slow. When it grows too large, the log is converted into a disk-optimized format, which is a rather quick process. This way, it can take tons of writes, service reads acceptably, while still being able to store much more data than RAM and offering fast access to on-disk data.
(this should apply equally to other databases that have a similar option)
>The preceding numbers are for an ext3 file system. Synchronous writes are much slower under ext4 (LevelDB drops to ~34 writes / second, TreeDB drops to ~5 writes / second; SQLite3 drops to ~24 writes / second) due to ext4's different handling of fsync / msync calls. Even LevelDB's asynchronous write performance drops somewhat since it spreads its storage across multiple files and issues fsync calls when switching to a new file.