News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Rawls: Visions of Justice by yboris on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @10:56AM (#28129617)
John Rawls made a mind-blowing mistake of not considering people outside of one's society as worthy of consideration.

His "veil of ignorance" (original idea by John Harsanyi not by Rawls) is great - but it focuses on one's society, ignoring the plight of the worst-off in other countries. Shame.

Re:John Rawls: Visions of Justice by woodruffw on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @11:01AM (#28129684)
> John Rawls made a mind-blowing mistake of not considering people outside of one's society as worthy of consideration.

I think this is a shortsighted reading of Rawls. AToJ refers specifically to societies and states because (some of) Rawls' ethical foundations begin in Piaget's tradition of social moral education, but nothing about either the Original Position or Veil of Ignorance is itself bound to a particular state or society.

Indeed, there's a thriving field of International Distributive Justice[1] that directly traces its lineage back to Rawls. No particular societal reference point is necessary.

(As a complete note, I'd actually argue an even stronger point: that Rawls is fundamentally a cosmopolitan ethicist, in the same tradition as (and building off of) Kant's thought in Perpetual Peace. But that's an entire tangent.)

[1]: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/international-justice/

Re:John Rawls: Visions of Justice by jonnycomputer on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @10:59AM (#28129649)
Can you provide a reference or quote that substantiates this? The word "society" is polysemous, so its not obvious to me that he meant any particular nation, or political unit, and not humanity as a whole.
Re:John Rawls: Visions of Justice by klaudius on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @11:27AM (#28130009)
It's also ignoring other species.