News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big Tech are supposed to be the plumbers, not patricians ... by whatshisface on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:20PM (#28110211)
Who gets to decide who goes to jail? All of the same fallibility arguments apply.
Re:Big Tech are supposed to be the plumbers, not patricians ... by dj_mc_merlin on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:25PM (#28110245)
Yes, I agree. My arguments extend to the law too. Previously, you could've gone to jail for being black or having a beer. Women got to vote in 1920.

I personally follow the law so I don't go to jail, since historically it has been made by idiots.

Re:Big Tech are supposed to be the plumbers, not patricians ... by bumby on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:31PM (#28110295)
I think the better answer is not “whom” but “what process”.

People will always be fallible. Processes, however, can layer checks and balances in a way that people often can’t. Processes are also easier to change than people in my experience.

Processes certainly aren’t perfect but considering your examples are past tense, they can tend to arc towards “more perfect.”

Re:Big Tech are supposed to be the plumbers, not patricians ... by dj_mc_merlin on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:39PM (#28110357)
I like this idea. Perhaps I'm committing the same fallacy that the Romans did around the fall of the Republic. The prevailing idea was that their problems were caused by a "failure of Roman morals", rather than by a failure of their system, even as they realized the inevitability of their situation and tried to enact changes.

> Processes certainly aren’t perfect but considering your examples are past tense, they can tend to arc towards “more perfect.”

Agreed. My use of the past was to illustrate a basic truth: given the big (colossal) failures of the past, is it more likely we have largely found the truth, or that we are still very far away from it? It's impossible to know of course. That said, the amount of people who will claim their truth is ultimate and all of who do not see it their way must be idiots is staggering. It's human nature though, I literally did that one comment above.

Re:Big Tech are supposed to be the plumbers, not patricians ... by shkkmo on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:00PM (#28110992)
Ideally? A jury of your peers supported by a system that at least purports to provide checks and balances against the system being dominated by any single person or groups' judgement.

If factual veracity faced a similar system that tries to balance the needs and desires of all participants, then censoring misinformation would be a lot more palatable (and would still, like our justice system, often be wrong.) The current system of supressing misinformation has none of the check and balances contained in the legal system and adding those in would do a great deal to facilitate trust in that system.