News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by gundmc on Saturday August 07, 2021 @04:23PM (#28101513)
I feel like this story is overblown. He was clearly a bad manager. From what I can gather, he was placed on leave after an investigation and then moved to a policy position where he does not manage anyone.

Calling it a promotion is pure spin.

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by Traster on Saturday August 07, 2021 @05:13PM (#28101882)
At my old company it was a bit of a joke, you would repeatedly see shit managers become "architect"s. Management were too cowardly to get rid of bad managers, so they were forced to promote them to get them out of their role. So managers who were shit technically constantly ended up with senior technical titles - and everyone knew why.
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by TeMPOraL on Saturday August 07, 2021 @05:42PM (#28102122)
Were they bad architects though?

It's easy to paint bad managers as bad workers (or even bad people) - but sometimes, they're just bad at managing. In such cases, it's better to shift them into roles they're more suited for than to fire them and hire new people for those roles - existing employees already know the company's procedures and products. Plus, it'll likely be cheaper salary-wise - in our industry, new employees have a much better negotiating position than existing ones.

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by ATsch on Saturday August 07, 2021 @06:09PM (#28102339)
Sorry, but a good architect bully is not a bit better than a bad manager bully.
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by maccard on Saturday August 07, 2021 @06:25PM (#28102444)
Someone who is a bad manager and a bully may actually be a fine architect and not a bully, once they are no longer in a position of power over people.

Not a guarantee, but in my experience changing the formal power dynamic can have very unexpected (both positive and negative) effects

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by edgyquant on Saturday August 07, 2021 @06:28PM (#28102464)
You can tell the architect with no power over you to, politely, go fuck themselves. You can not do this to your manager.
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by squarefoot on Saturday August 07, 2021 @06:53PM (#28102600)
True, although in a few cases I've witnessed the bully without superpowers becoming a lapdog of some higher level boss, so essentially all he had to do was go crying mommy to the boss to have someone moved to other tasks or fired. Bad bosses need lapdogs.
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by edgyquant on Sunday August 08, 2021 @01:23AM (#28104396)
Yeah but that seems like it’d be time to look for work elsewhere
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by ATsch on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:19AM (#28104834)
This is very naive but more importantly, there are more than enough engineers out there that there's no need to risk creating a hostile workplace by employing bullies anywhere in your organisation.

Why are you so intent in employing them?

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by shadowgovt on Saturday August 07, 2021 @05:59PM (#28102266)
Google is generally loathe to fire unless they absolutely have to, so this explanation tracks.
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by AlbertCory on Saturday August 07, 2021 @07:28PM (#28102812)
What's your evidence for that statement?

I worked there 11 1/2 years, and by the way was not fired. However, I saw many people fired. There were probably many more placed on a Performance Improvement Plan who subsequently quit rather than get fired.

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by shadowgovt on Saturday August 07, 2021 @10:34PM (#28103787)
My evidence is all the coworkers I saw who didn't get fired.

To clarify: I mean in the rank and file software engineering. If you make legal's job hard or give the company a public black eye, that can be a short path to dismissal.

(It's a big company, so I wouldn't be surprised if, perhaps, it also varies from department to department. I have no idea if the YouTube piece and the ads piece have the same policies).

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:27PM (#28107891)
You'd have to compare the firing rate at Google to other large companies, and that would be very difficult data to gather. Particularly when "firing" can take the form of the manager telling someone "you might want to start looking for another job."
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by ramraj07 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @07:16PM (#28102736)
Except if it’s a black female AI ethicist questioning some choices made by your company I suppose.
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by geofft on Saturday August 07, 2021 @06:18PM (#28102403)
How can you possibly be a good architect if you're a bad manager?

Every skill of a good manager - having good working relationships and pleasant interpersonal relations, understanding conflicting needs from different teams, building trust, being able to schedule and prioritize work, etc. - is also a skill of a good architect. If you're off in a corner developing things by yourself, you're not an architect, you're an individual-contributor team of one (or if they're not getting implemented at all, you're just wasting the company's money). If you're actually designing architectures that other people will be following or implementing, you need to be able to work with people.

The balance of work is different, of course: for instance, architects will less often (but not never!) need to have difficult one-on-one conversations. I can understand someone preferring one role or the other, of course. I can't really understand how you can be a good architect, not just a mediocre one, if you're a bad manager, not just a mediocre one.

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by edgyquant on Saturday August 07, 2021 @06:27PM (#28102457)
I think it’s pretty straightforward. When we’re young we often see friends, at our early jobs, who are good workers but get promoted and become mean + stop working as hard. Some people just aren’t good at managing other people but are still skilled at their trade.
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by TeMPOraL on Saturday August 07, 2021 @08:08PM (#28103035)
I disagree. Your description of an architect sounds to me like an artifact of current workplace trends - which are to punt managerial duties and responsibilities to people as they get promoted, without giving them corresponding authority.

Architects should architect. There are some social skills requirement that come with any collaborative position within a company, but I see no reason why an architect should be expected to have managerial-level social skills, vs. senior-developer-level ones. There's nothing in the actual job of architecting software systems that requires it.

But to be explicit about my original point: managing is a completely different type of job than writing code or architecting systems. It's a whole specialty on its own. Not everyone has the necessary organizational and social skill set. It's learnable to a large degree, but that takes time. Just because someone sucks as a manager doesn't mean they're a bad employee or a bad human in general - it only means they don't have the specialized skills necessary for that particular role.

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by TheSpiceIsLife on Saturday August 07, 2021 @07:57PM (#28102984)
I think the difference is a good manager will be good at difficult one on one meetings with subordinates as part of their job on a regular basis. They’re good at the hard bits of soft squishy things with complex needs.

An architect may have the occasional difficult meeting with other stakeholders from time to time, but their regular role is not managing people.

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by artursapek on Saturday August 07, 2021 @07:28PM (#28102814)
Serious question: why would management be too cowardly to get rid of someone being an asshole?
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by harikb on Saturday August 07, 2021 @07:42PM (#28102901)
Only because it is usually very hard to determine how the current projects will be affected if one gets rid of a particular manager. So the next level manager will always take the path of least resistance / least risk and move the person to a different role while having some smooth transition on projects. In reality, more often that not, this is completely unnecessary. But the person making the decision outweighs their project’s success more than the wastage of an unproductive employee. Basically a form of kicking that can down the road.
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by TeeMassive on Saturday August 07, 2021 @06:10PM (#28102348)
At this point I'd just leave. This is an employee market now. Promotions are made by changing jobs anyway. Be sure to leave the proper feedback when leaving (what are they gonna do, fire you?)
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by TheSpiceIsLife on Saturday August 07, 2021 @08:04PM (#28103019)
It’s pervasive though.

Out of the frying pan in to the fire.

I’d hazard a guess if you ask at an interview if they have any bullies working there they’re either going to lie and / or you’re not going to get the job.

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by whalesalad on Saturday August 07, 2021 @07:51PM (#28102953)
Did you miss the whole “I crush people” sociopath situation?
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by truetraveller on Saturday August 07, 2021 @05:58PM (#28102262)
This is today's cancel culture, unfortunately. Dramatize and exaggerate things. And hypocrisy, but that's a separate issue.
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by jmeister on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:53PM (#28104083)
This is just a consequence of feminization of society.

I used to work on Wall St, and it’s a rite of passage there for senior people to send juniors to fetch cigars or lunchboxes. I’ve seen execs angrily bang on glass walls of their cabins so hard, hundreds on the open-floor outside would notice.

Two quotes from Camille Paglia:

“There is no female Mozart because there is no female Jack-the-Ripper.”

You have to tolerate deviance if you want to accommodate world-class talent. Mozart himself would’ve been cancelled by today’s standards for being a boor and a creep.

“If civilization was left in female hands, we’d still be living in grass huts.”

I hope the adults in the business world can step up and stem this tide, or else we are on our way back to grass huts.

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by bob_roberts on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:50AM (#28104954)
> This is just a consequence of feminization of society.

I'd say you're using misogyny to justify what sounds like very typical toxic masculinity.

Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by ace_of_spades on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:47AM (#28104710)
wow, so much missing nuance and little actual understanding… I am not religious but bless your soul… is all I want to say to this
Re:After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullyi... by truetraveller on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:15AM (#28104162)
It's not feminization of society. That is IMHO a misogynistic way of thinking. It is the hyper-sensitivity, sensationalism and hypocrisy. Just look at this thread.

I am Muslim, so Richard Dawkins is someone I do not espouse at all. But it was upsetting (even a little funny) to see him being cancelled by the humanist society. And him a chief supporter of humanism! See this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3SsHhgeAAhM