I think this is exactly what Apple wants to he the result of their their iMessage scanning.
They are not in this to make arrests. They just want parents to feel safe letting children use their products. Driving predators to use different tools is fine with them.
As far as the FBI goes, this is presumably not their preference, but it’s still good for them if it makes predation a little harder.
Why limit it to child predators? Why not use this too for terrorists and anyone the FBI or any other government deems as subversive?
In fact, if you just look at what the FBI has been saying over the years, that is exactly what they intend to do.
People who say that this is a slippery slope argument don’t even notice that they have been sliding down that slippery slope for decades.
If they wanted to, they could have done this silently, years ago when the Neural Engine was first released. This is at least an attempt at a transparent, privacy-oriented approach. And it opens the door to more E2EE content in iCloud without the government openly accusing them of enabling distribution of abusive content.
If we want to limit the damage caused by the dynamic, we need to offer better solutions, not just complain about the FBI.
The solution for child porn isn’t found in snooping on everyone. It is in infiltrating the networks. Go have the FBI infiltrate the rings. Here is an example of why the FBI is disingenuous. This child porn ring wasn’t using phones. Guess what they were using?
https://abc7.com/archive/7844451/
Computers in public libraries
Like I said, sophisticated actors aren’t the targets.
Another example. Osama bin Laden. He was air gapped. No cell phones or computers for him. No one even calling on a phone nearby. Osama bin Laden was found via an informant.
The next actor will be even more sophisticated. Probably single use dumb paired cell phones with call locations randomized. Probably plastic surgery. Locations that spy satellites cannot see.
Did snooping on cell phone data help find Osama? When that wasn’t enough, did grabbing all online data help? How about grabbing data straight from smart phones? Nope. Nope. Nope. Yet governments want more, more, more. Why do you think snooping helps against people who don’t even use phones for their most private communications?
From Wikipedia’s entry for slippery slope: “The fallacious sense of "slippery slope" is often used synonymously with continuum fallacy, in that it ignores the possibility of middle ground”
This isn’t a middle ground. Every year the supposed middle ground shifts toward less and less privacy. Notice the slippery slope? The very presence of this means that the supposed middle ground just slipped further?
Isn’t that obvious?
> These are clearly real concerns and even Tim Cook admits that if you build a back door, bad people will use it.
I’m not the one ignoring the middle ground.
What disingenuous argument have I made?
The only thing I have argued for is for hackers to attempt technical solutions that are more to their liking than Apple’s, because arguments are not preventing the slide.
Basically the argument I hear from you is “If you build a back door, then people will use it. So let’s build it anyway because it is a middle ground.” The problem I have with it is the “let’s build it anyway”.
That seems as clear as day. Why do I have to keep repeating myself? Don’t be an apologist.
This looks a completely made up position that has nothing to do with anything I have said. If you can find a comment where I am advocating building back doors, I invite you to quote it.
> That seems as clear as day. Why do I have to keep repeating myself?
If it was clear you’d be able to support it with a quote. I’m pretty sure you can’t.
> Don’t be an apologist.
It doesn’t seem like you have been following my argument, so it’s unclear why you’d stoop to a personal attack.
zepto “As far as I can see: 1. This is a serious attempt to build a privacy preserving solution to child pornography.”
“ > The more sophisticated child molesters out there will find out about what Apple is doing and quickly avoid it. <- this is you quoting me
I think this is exactly what Apple wants to he the result of their their iMessage scanning. They are not in this to make arrests. They just want parents to feel safe letting children use their products. Driving predators to use different tools is fine with them.”
So according to your very own words, this ISN’T a serious attempt to build a privacy supporting solution to child pornography. First, it isn’t a solution because as you stated, it won’t actually catch anyone. Second, it isn’t serious because it was never intended to catch anyone.
“2. The complaints are all slippery slope arguments that governments will force Apple to abuse the mechanism. These are clearly real concerns and even Tim Cook admits that if you build a back door, bad people will use it.”
So according to your words these are not slippery slope arguments (the invalid argument sense) since, as you state, if you build a back door, bad people will use it. Don’t subtly use negative connotations to try to advance your argument.
Next you disingenuously frame the problem as a conflict between privacy and child pornography. That is an unsupported dichotomy.
“ However: Child pornography and the related abuse is widely thought of as a massive problem, that is facilitated by encrypted communication and digital photography. People do care about this issue. ‘Think of the children’ is a great pretext for increasing surveillance, because it isn’t an irrational fear.”
Lastly you call for better solutions for a “solution” that actually isn’t a solution.
“So: where are the proposals for a better solution?”
“ Apple’s solution is the best on offer. ”
Another unsupported dichotomy and a false assignment of responsibility.
If this solution is bad, then toss it out. You don’t need another proposal in its place. You don’t need to deploy this backdoor in the meantime.
It is NOT our responsibility to do the FBI’s job. It is THEIR responsibility to come up with better proposals.
If you do actually want a solution, my recommendation is to concentrate on real harm like child molestation and child trafficking. Trace how children have been trafficked historically. See how you can shut that down.
I feel dirty analyzing all the dirty tricks that you employed. Are you a politician or do you work for one? Work on policy?
That isn’t what you’ve done.
“As far as I can see: 1. This is a serious attempt to build a privacy preserving solution to child pornography.”
- False as you even argued
I don’t argue that.
>> They are not in this to make arrests. They just want parents to feel safe letting children use their products. Driving predators to use different tools is fine with them.”
> So according to your very own words,
Erm..
> this ISN’T a serious attempt to build a privacy supporting solution to child pornography.
These are your words, not what you quoted of mine.
It’s absolutely a solution to the problem of child porn on their platform. They care about making it safe for their users. Who is expecting Apple to solve the problem beyond that?
> It is at best something to keep the FBI at bay
These are your words, not something I have said.
> even though as you say it also introduces a back door.
Where do I say it introduces a back door?
> “2. The complaints are all slippery slope arguments that governments will force Apple to abuse the mechanism. These are clearly real concerns and even Tim Cook admits that if you build a back door, bad people will use it.”
> False, these are not slippery slope arguments
It is your opinion that they are not slippery slope arguments. I think they are, and as you have quoted I think they are reasonable. Slippery slope arguments are fallacies in the sense that the conclusions don’t logically follow, but that doesn’t mean that they are always wrong.
You haven’t hung me with anything - you’ve just voiced some misrepresentations of your own interleaved with quotes of me.
““ As far as I can see: 1. This is a serious attempt to build a privacy preserving solution to child pornography.” I don’t argue that.””
“ Apple’s solution is the best on offer. ”
“ I think this is exactly what Apple wants to he the result of their their iMessage scanning. They are not in this to make arrests. They just want parents to feel safe letting children use their products. Driving predators to use different tools is fine with them.”
“2. The complaints are all slippery slope arguments that governments will force Apple to abuse the mechanism. These are clearly real concerns and even Tim Cook admits that if you build a back door, bad people will use it.”
“So: where are the proposals for a better solution?”
Let the viewer decide. Are you going to argue that I have misrepresented your words? Feel free to argue with yourself.
“ As far as I can see: 1. This is a serious attempt to build a privacy preserving solution to child pornography. 2. The complaints are all slippery slope arguments that governments will force Apple to abuse the mechanism. These are clearly real concerns and even Tim Cook admits that if you build a back door, bad people will use it. However: Child pornography and the related abuse is widely thought of as a massive problem, that is facilitated by encrypted communication and digital photography. People do care about this issue. ‘Think of the children’ is a great pretext for increasing surveillance, because it isn’t an irrational fear. So: where are the proposals for a better solution? I see here people who themselves are afraid of the real consequences of government/corporate surveillance, and whose fear prevents them from empathizing with the people who are afraid of the equally real consequences of organized child sexual exploitation. ‘My fear is more important than your fear’, is the root of ordinary political polarization. What would be a hacker alternative would be to come up with a technical solution that solves for both fears at the same time. This is what Apple has attempted, but the wisdom here is that they have failed. Can anyone propose anything better, or are we stuck with just politics as usual? Edit: added ‘widely thought of as’ to make it clear that I am referring to a widely held position, not that I am arguing for it.”
> The more sophisticated child molesters out there will find out about what Apple is doing and quickly avoid it. I think this is exactly what Apple wants to he the result of their their iMessage scanning. They are not in this to make arrests. They just want parents to feel safe letting children use their products. Driving predators to use different tools is fine with them. As far as the FBI goes, this is presumably not their preference, but it’s still good for them if it makes predation a little harder.
Did you know they can still be seen exactly as I wrote them in the thread, where anyone can make sense of them, and see what I was replying to?
Remind us what this copy and paste behavior is meant to prove?
They turned a trillion dollars of devices into iNarcs—without asking.
I am sure this will appeal to people who already agree with you.
There is nothing to ‘hang’ anyone with. Just a series of quotes taken out of context which even then don’t look particularly nefarious.
Remind us again what you’re trying to prove with this?
The more sophisticated child molesters out there will find out about what Apple is doing and quickly avoid it. Isn’t that what the FBI is complaining about, that they have grown increasingly sophisticated?
The more sophisticated privacy adherents will also avoid Apple and resort to end to encryption and offline tools.
What is the actual outcome? You won’t get more arrests of child molesters. Instead, you get a security apparatus that can be weaponized against the masses. Furthermore, you will have the FBI complaining that child molesters are increasingly out of their reach and demanding greater powers. They will then try to mandate child porn detectors built into every phone.
This creep has been occurring for years. Go read the Snowden disclosures.
First your cell phone companies worked with the government for mass harvesting of data. No need for any suspicion because they promise not to look unless there is one. That wasn’t enough because the data was encrypted.
Second they had the companies holding the data snoop in on data that was shared. That wasn’t enough.
Third they had the companies holding the data snoop in on data EVEN when it wasn’t shared, just when it was uploaded to them. Not enough for them!
Now they will have it done on device prior to uploading. Does this mean that if it fails to upload, it gets scanned anyway. Why yes!
Next they will have it done on device even if it never is held by the company and never shared and never even intended to be uploaded.
The obvious goal is that the government has access to ALL data in the name of safety. No need for warrants. Don’t worry about it. They won’t look unless there was any suspicion. Opps never mind that, we will just have tools look.
There is no end to the loss of privacy in the name of safety if your bogeyman is increasingly sophisticated actors.
Why isn’t this obvious to everyone?
Anyone old enough to remember the Clipper chips?