As someone who lived in Italy and Pakistan all her K-12 education years, your comment is so damn off base. Are you seriously saying that India (and Pakistan for that matter) have the same racial dynamic as America? Yes, India is diverse. Yes, we are not all the same. But that is not akin to the racial structures I have seen in the US.

Are you sure you read that comment correctly? It seems to me to be making the same point that you are, i.e. exactly the opposite of how you've interpreted it.

Indian Muslims, a group that experiences increasing marginalization within that large diverse country; would probably not