Why not? The infrastructure is being paid for in part by this tax. They're fundamentally linked.
There are a few reasons for this. One is that it is easier to keep track from the public perspective. A title should reflect the contents of the bill (in this case it is not obvious that bitcoin regulations are part of infrastructure). This could help reduce confusion and manipulation. It helps with transparency because it reduces the cognitive load (Note we can still talk about a "plan" or "package" that is a group of bills and so many conversations would stay the same).
The second part is that it helps reduce squabbling over nuance. A current bill might be 99% agreeable but that 1% is pretty contentious. If it was more compartmentalized then we could pass 99% of those things and get them in place faster rather than throwing the entire thing in the trash and restructuring (which often links back to the first point). This also reduces some of the toxic nature in politics where sometimes politicians add a component to nuke their own proposals so they can complain about it to their party's constituents.
This can probably be improved upon a lot but I think highlights the frustration with how things are done today and people are looking for systematic changes to fix those problems.
And most of these things would simply never pass as standalone bills, being too small and local for Congress as a whole, and too expensive or cross-jurisdictional for state governments.
Why is this a problem? I see it as easier to call out politicians in public. Prevent the problems that are essentially: "Despite the 'Puppy and Sunshine' bill actually providing everyone with puppies and sunshine, we can't support it because it also summons the literal anti-christ to destroy the Earth. The puppies and sunshine is simply a trick to summon the anti-christ."
IMO doing so makes the bill far more transparent _to the public_.
> Riders and earmarks allow politicians to secure minor wins that they can sell to their electorate as the reason for supporting a bill.
I do not understand why such a thing could not happen without these nor with packages (as defined above).
> And most of these things would simply never pass as standalone bills
Do you not see that as a problem?
Was this edgy strawman really useful?
> IMO doing so makes the bill far more transparent _to the public_.
How? The public that are engaged are still almost entirely getting their knowledge through the media, and they won't cover small bills due to lack of journalists, and more importantly, because readers aren't interested in them. I'm not sure who this mythical cohort who want to understand more about e.g. legislation that involves federal spending in Ohio, but can only do so by looking at every single small bill until they find "The Providing Ohio Reinvestment Kickback Bill" on page 23.
> I do not understand why such a thing could not happen without these nor with packages (as defined above).
Because there is only so much time available to get bills passed if nothing else, a bill focussing solely on niche and/or local issues are going to get bumped down the queue at every stage - in committee, getting scored for budgetary implications, getting floor time etc. - and there are two houses to make it worse.
> Do you not see that as a problem?
Well that depends on what it actually was of course.
The US system of government is at every level designed to prevent getting anything done, and so lots of things get lumped onto big bills that are likely to pass. I mean there's even a literal "omnibus bill" FFS. But the alternative is that "$1,000,000 for additional spaces at homeless shelters for transgender youth" isn't ever going to get to the floor, let alone pass in the House and get 60 votes in the Senate.
This isn't actually a (new) tax, it's a surveillance framework intended to support stricter enforcement of existing taxes. So far as that goes it's an added expense (mostly externalized) and not likely to pay for anything. The claim is that there is $28 billion of tax evasion going on which all this extra reporting would supposedly curtail–assuming all else remained equal—which is pure conjecture and not something that should be relied upon as a funding source.
(Because Bitcoin is psuedonymous it would have effectively be impossible to comply - functionally it was a ban on crypto mining in the US)
Even with the original language, this provision generates no revenue. It's only about data collection.
I would want to see an independent analysis of this claim.
Increasing reporting requirements can generate revenue. There is a lot of unreported income. Given the culture around crypto, it isn't unreasonable to assume there is more of that going on there than baseline.
Effectively, I think what would have happened if this was enacted would be that all legitimate mining operations would move out of US, and the IRS still wouldn't get much data, just less tax revenue because those profits are no longer occurring on US soil by US entities.
Exempting actors in the crypto space who facillitate crypto usage without ever having custodial control of the funds makes a lot of sense. (Just like envelope manufacturers shouldn't have to register as money transmitters because people sometimes mail cash.) The provision that was slid in was nonsensically bad.