Re:Ethereum just activated its ‘London’ hard fork
by dyndos on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:34PM
(#28076031)
It's not about distributed governance; it's about abusing a dominant role in consensus. PoS is easier to capture, allowing the dominant party to censor and manipulate the settlement chain.
As for governance, with Bitcoin everyone is equally powerless to dictate how things should go. If you appreciate the fixed ruleset, you can choose to participate.
Ethereum is far more nebulous, being piloted by a foundation which hardforks the protocol at will.
Re:Ethereum just activated its ‘London’ hard fork
by skybrian on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:54PM
(#28076343)
Okay, but in practice you’re going to trade on an exchange, which can… do whatever it wants?
Re:Ethereum just activated its ‘London’ hard fork
by dyndos on Friday August 06, 2021 @03:44PM
(#28091901)
I don't trade, I accumulate. Through a handful of different exchanges, and then withdraw.
If I had to, I could plug an ASIC into the wall and 'trade' energy value for bitcoin directly with the network.
While it’s true that you can’t buy Bitcoin (for example) unless someone else is selling, most people aren’t concerned about market liquidity for buyers due to whales being unwilling to sell. The permission to buy doesn’t seem hard to get?
Also, for the most part, people are happy when the price goes up, which is what happens when there are more buyers than sellers.
I guess in theory, money drops could distribute ownership more widely and that would be more equitable, but this sort of inequality (some people have a lot more Bitcoin than others) isn’t normally considered too much of a problem.
But if you’re going to take distributed governance seriously, neither proof-of-work nor proof-of-stake give ordinary people much of a say in how things go. In this way it’s similar to the stock market, where we’re told our votes are meaningful but in practice they aren’t unless you have a huge amount of shares. Participating in governance is usually an illusion and it’s not normally why you invest, unless you’re a corporate raider or something.
Similarly for mining. It’s done to make money.