But I have to compare it to the alternatives and those do not convince at all.
There is no purely rational and selfless comittee. How would such a group be less self-interested and less vulnerable to group-think? Or less ideological or prejudiced? Because they have some self-imposed mission to a higher cause? Who doesn't?
You can have your benevolent dictator that handles logistical problems of exposure to ideas, but the less error prone way to get the best ideas implemented is a mechanism to boot him out, or in other words, his ideas need justification on the marketplace of ideas. So I must always allow objections.
In the pro-choise vs pro-life case, should the wrong side be blocked from publishing adds?
What about drinking alcohol at 18? It's legal in most of the world.
Who is going to decide in each case? Are you sure they will have the same opinion than you?
Even within a single mind we see people regularly holding two contradictory beliefs and accepting both of them, so if the marketplace of ideas fails in a single mind then I think is has little luck when it encounters large populations.