Re:Aaron Swartz v. United States
by nitrogen on Tuesday July 26, 2011 @01:26AM
(#2806092)
This question, of "mens rea", is I think reasonably established in the charging documents by things like MAC address spoofing.
On this point specifically I hope that, if it would be beneficial and accurate, Swartz's attorneys bring up the point that:
1. Programmers routinely work around various limitations to do their jobs.
2. Those limitations may originate in the laws of physics, limitations of current technology, or excessively strict corporate IT policies.
3. Those workarounds may include changing MAC addresses, connecting to a different switch port, etc.
4. Therefore, a programmer such as Swartz would have considered his actions in an engineering context. Overcoming any blocking or access rate limitations imposed automatically by JSTOR's systems would be seen by Swartz in the same light as bypassing a faulty router or otherwise routing around network damage, rather than as a specifically legal affront.
5. Thus, at first glance, mens rea is not present.
On this point specifically I hope that, if it would be beneficial and accurate, Swartz's attorneys bring up the point that:
1. Programmers routinely work around various limitations to do their jobs.
2. Those limitations may originate in the laws of physics, limitations of current technology, or excessively strict corporate IT policies.
3. Those workarounds may include changing MAC addresses, connecting to a different switch port, etc.
4. Therefore, a programmer such as Swartz would have considered his actions in an engineering context. Overcoming any blocking or access rate limitations imposed automatically by JSTOR's systems would be seen by Swartz in the same light as bypassing a faulty router or otherwise routing around network damage, rather than as a specifically legal affront.
5. Thus, at first glance, mens rea is not present.