News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by tzs on Monday July 25, 2011 @06:04PM (#2804911)
Considering that one of the biggest names in computing in the eyes of the public (IBM) in extremely pro-software patents, that's not likely to happen. IBM says:

   Given the reality that software source code is human
   readable, and object code can be reverse engineered,
   it is difficult for software developers to resort to
   secrecy. Thus, without patent protection, the incentives
   to innovate in the field of software are significantly
   reduced. Patent protection has promoted the free sharing
   of source code on a patentee’s terms—which has fueled the
   explosive growth of open source software development.
That's from their brief to the Supreme Court for the Bilski case.
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by modeless on Monday July 25, 2011 @06:17PM (#2804975)
Patent protection has fueled the growth of open source? That's the funniest thing I've read all year.
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by tzs on Monday July 25, 2011 @06:50PM (#2805093)
Then you should get a copy of the full brief and read it, as you'll probably get a good laugh from more of it, like where they say software patents encourage the adoption of standards on the web and net.
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by josephcooney on Monday July 25, 2011 @06:37PM (#2805043)
I think the general public would stab their local IBM Global Services consultant in the eye with a pen if they thought it would help their beloved Angry Birds in the patent dispute.
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by awj on Monday July 25, 2011 @07:00PM (#2805114)
> Given the reality that software source code is human readable, and object code can be reverse engineered[...]

It's now abundantly clear that this argument was put before someone who is not familiar with the difficulty inherent in divining the intent of original source code, much less source that has been reverse engineered off the opcodes.

Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by loup-vaillant on Monday July 25, 2011 @07:28PM (#2805197)
So, they are deliberately misleading the judges. I really would like that to be recognized as "lying under oath" (or is there no oath attached to such briefs?).
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by awj on Monday July 25, 2011 @08:00PM (#2805303)
My comment was meant at least slightly tongue-in-cheek. I've seen some people (usually pretty deep compiler experts) who were able to do a remarkable job of reconstructing original source from object code. There obviously is brilliantly written source code out there that is a downright pleasure to read.

In general we don't enact legislation entirely against the worst cases, for good reason.

Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by loup-vaillant on Tuesday July 26, 2011 @04:54AM (#2806571)
OK, my bad.
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by artsrc on Monday July 25, 2011 @08:22PM (#2805376)
It seems to me that it is the obscurity of source code that enables copyright violation.

If software could not be copyright unless it was registered with the library of congress, then the library could run a filter on all new arrivals and check they were different from previously posted source from other sources.

Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by rbanffy on Monday July 25, 2011 @11:33PM (#2805872)
What if two people independently arrive at thesame algorithm, say, an optimal implementation with the least possible amount of code in a given language. Is it still a copyright violation? You can't copyright math, can you?
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by artsrc on Tuesday July 26, 2011 @02:20AM (#2806213)
Legally that is not a copyright violation. There are examples where this is likely, and companies make efforts to prove this no copying occurred. I think this is called a 'clean room' implementation.

   http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by palish on Monday July 25, 2011 @06:38PM (#2805051)

  Thus, without patent protection, the incentives
  to innovate in the field of software are significantly
  reduced.
... Right ...
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by sjs on Monday July 25, 2011 @08:46PM (#2805454)
In theory it seems like it should though doesn't it?

Maybe if we did something to fix the problems it wouldn't be so bad. Right now it's hard for little guys to get patents, partly because it costs a lot of money and time (lawyers are expensive). It's also too easy to patent trivial things so big companies can patent the simplest things at a relatively minuscule cost for them.

Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by palish on Monday July 25, 2011 @08:48PM (#2805460)
In theory, theory seems like practice. In practice, it isn't.
Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by wnight on Tuesday July 26, 2011 @04:26AM (#2806520)
You're asking if monopolies, on technical solutions, being handed out by necessarily under-skilled government bureaucrats, sound like they'd help spur innovation?

Umm, no. Not in the slightest. Do you live in backwards day?

If we wanted to reward innovation we'd reward innovators. Instead of wasting money on patents and court we'd give it to people who (according to their peers) did the most to help us. No forms, no lawyers, just grants to helpful inventors and teachers.

Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by sjs on Tuesday July 26, 2011 @11:38AM (#2807813)
Temporary monopolies. That's pretty key and you omitted it entirely.

> If we wanted to reward innovation we'd reward innovators. Instead of wasting money on patents and court we'd give it to people who (according to their peers) did the most to help us. No forms, no lawyers, just grants to helpful inventors and teachers.

So inventor X spends 5 years to research and make a cool thing and we grant him $1 million, after which the big corporations copy his idea and make billions. If he could have licensed his idea for the couple of years he had exclusive rights to it that makes it far more worthwhile for the inventor.

Also, where does the money for these grants come from? Shouldn't big corporations with billions have to pay to profit wildly from brand new inventions?

You're also ignoring the potential for corruption. Honestly, your plan is pretty naïve for this modern world. Instead of throwing out what we have we could try to fix it. At least we know some of the current problems, we have no idea what problems some other brand new scheme would have or how corporations and lawyers would twist it to serve their purposes.

Re:Angry Birds Maker Sued for Patent Violation by wnight on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @04:48AM (#2811352)
> Temporary monopolies. That's pretty key and you omitted it entirely.

Oh yeah, never mind the government interference - it's only temporary. Never mind that it's still six times longer than the lifetime of the tech involved. Just like how copyrights are 'for a limited time' despite being longer than the average lifespan.

No, what's key here is untrained and uninterested people trying to provide a stimulus to something they don't understand by handing out monopolies on development. If you were to invent an analogy suitably horrible it would involve blind people and hand grenades.

> So inventor X spends 5 years to research and make a cool thing and we grant him $1 million, after which the big corporations copy his idea and make billions. If he could have licensed his idea for the couple of years he had exclusive rights to it that makes it far more worthwhile for the inventor.

And if wishes were unicorns... But back on planet Earth, patents only screw over inventors. Make a mistake in your paperwork and it's worthless. Don't file on time, worthless. Can't afford legal battles, worthless.

That million dollars that you scoff at would certainly be comforting to the 99.986% of independent inventors who don't win patent-bingo though. And teachers, authors, etc, would be eligible for this, unlike now.

> Also, where does the money for these grants come from?

From the dismantled patent system and the court costs that go to adjudicating it. Also, the innovative gains and lessened frictional costs of patents would mean higher profits and thus tax revenue.

Think what we might accomplish if every patent attorney and everyone involved in the industry stopped throwing their life's effort into a productivity black-hole and did even one useful thing with the time, instead of dragging everyone down to provide a relative boost to their team.

> Shouldn't big corporations with billions have to pay to profit wildly from brand new inventions?

Under this scheme they'd pay whatever you wanted to tax them, much like now.

But why should someone have to pay to use an idea just because someone else (might have) had it first? As long as you operate from ridiculous premises like that you'll keep coming up with solutions to non-problems - like patents.

> You're also ignoring the potential for corruption. Honestly, your plan is pretty naïve for this modern world. Instead of throwing out what we have we could try to fix it.

As my system could be expressed in about a page of non-legalese, I'd wager it'd have one ten-millionth the loopholes and cruft the patent system is carrying and would thus a lot less likely to be subverted.

But even if my system were totally corrupted it'd, at absolute worst, reward the wrong people. The patent system, on a good day, brings ruin and destruction to many worthwhile companies and ideas. Engineers are told (on sound legal advice) to never look at patents so the theoretical benefits to society aren't even being provided.

The patent system is already a run-away worst-case scenario.