News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by dragontamer on Monday August 02, 2021 @06:14PM (#28043368)
> If you look at what is happening today, this call for censorship in the name of combating disinformation has actually had no effect on disinformation.

You say that, but ISIS propaganda has been soundly defeated outside of fringe sites like GETTR. And sure, GETTR remains a hotbed of terrible disinformation (such as this ISIS propaganda), but without a mainstream audience, its much less of an issue compared to giving it out to everyone on Twitter.

You can't post an ISIS sponsored beheading video on a mainstream site (Youtube, Facebook, Twitter) without the moderators noticing and censoring it in short order.

Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by babesh on Monday August 02, 2021 @07:00PM (#28043766)
The harm caused by censorship is so much greater. Look at censorship in the old Soviet Union, present day China, 50s McCarthy era US, North Korea, present day Brazil, India, solidarity era Poland, etc… It isn’t a tool for combating disinformation. It is a tool for suppressing dissent.

Also your logic and example are faulty. A beheading video is not disinformation. It is terror. It is a threat to those that oppose ISIS that that would befall them. Also, if you haven’t noticed, ISIS is about to retake Afghanistan. Getting rid of that video did nothing.

https://news.yahoo.com/mapping-advance-taliban-afghanistan-2...

Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by dragontamer on Monday August 02, 2021 @07:10PM (#28043854)
The Taliban is about to retake Afghanistan, which is a different group than ISIS / ISIL.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taliban%E2%80%93ISIL_conflict_...

In fact, Taliban and ISIL are at war with each other for Afghanistan right now. In any case, we've been incredibly successful at censoring both of them from our mainstream platforms.

They wish for recruitment, to spread their propaganda / disinformation, and to grow their cause. Its an information war, the same as any other.

Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by babesh on Monday August 02, 2021 @07:16PM (#28043898)
Censorship is a tool, not a goal. The goal was control of Afghanistan. Go look at the map of control. The Taliban have made great gains and the US and allies basically are giving up because they have bigger fish to fry. As noted, the censorship wasn’t about disinformation, it was and is just about power.
Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by dragontamer on Monday August 02, 2021 @07:23PM (#28043971)
Censorship is a tool. The goal was to prevent Daesh / ISIS from recruiting Americans into dying for their cause in Syria / Iraq.

The number of US citizens flying out to die in a forsaken war on ISIS's side are miniscule to none. Believe it or not, American citizens were doing this back when the surge was happening.

We successfully disrupted their information campaign and their recruitment. And ISIS / ISIL / Daesh is now fighting for relevance (albeit unsuccessfully, mainly on GETTR).

Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by spfzero on Tuesday August 03, 2021 @12:08AM (#28045620)
They never needed American recruits. This is a sideshow. There are many millions of non-Americans in the world to recruit from, and many non-internet ways to do it.
Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by dragontamer on Tuesday August 03, 2021 @09:41AM (#28049027)
ISIL didn't exist a few years ago. They only came into existence thanks to foreign recruits.

Americans included of course. But there are recruits from all around the world. Disrupting that recruitment process is one of the shining examples of effective cyber warfare vs ISIL / daesh.

Non-Americans use Facebook, YouTube, and other websites in large numbers.

-------

ISIL is still trying to recruit from the US websites. We just censor the crap out of them so they make no progress. It's in fact, proof that censorship works in practice.

Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by b0tzzzzzzman on Monday August 02, 2021 @09:25PM (#28044743)
What are the bigger fish? Could you elaborate?
Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by babesh on Tuesday August 03, 2021 @12:18AM (#28045678)
There are articles on the Internet that say that the US is withdrawing to focus on the great powers competition (basically China). It doesn’t have the extra resources to burn on Afghanistan and Iraq anymore. The US has also drawn down troops from Iraq.
Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by Retric on Tuesday August 03, 2021 @07:55AM (#28048157)
The drawdown from Afghanistan started 10 years ago. The last remnants leaving are largely symbolic from a cost and manpower standpoint.

US soldiers killed in Afghanistan is a reasonable proxy for number of soldiers actively engaged, 2009: 310, 2010: 496, 2011: 412, 2012: 301, 2013: 120, 2014: 2014, 2015: 22, 2016: 14, 2017: 17, 2018: 15, 2019: 22

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_military_casualt...

Looking at just combat fatalities and the difference is even more obvious. 440 KIA in 2010 down to 11 in 2015.

Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by babesh on Tuesday August 03, 2021 @12:28PM (#28051120)
I don’t think this dismisses the cost and the strategic implications. The US/China rivalry was recognized even 10 years ago.
Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by cabalamat on Monday August 02, 2021 @07:33PM (#28044042)
> You say that, but ISIS propaganda has been soundly defeated outside of fringe sites like GETTR.

Really? It took me approximately 15 seconds to find and red ISIS's magazine Dabiq (and not on GETTR, which I had previously not heard of).

Re:The Push for a “PBS for the Internet” by p1necone on Monday August 02, 2021 @10:15PM (#28045035)
Yes but you had to:

. Know about ISIS

. Know they had a magazine

. Actually want to read it

This is different from ISIS propaganda being algorithmically suggested to you from a seemingly normal website like YouTube without you even seeking it out in the first place because some faceless algorithm values "engagement" over everything else.