News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aaron Swartz v. United States by tptacek on Monday July 25, 2011 @03:12PM (#2804117)
JSTOR's particular collection of documents is protected by copyright and has been valued, by virtually every one of the most learned and respected educational institutions in the country, at millions of dollars annually.

Let's say I come into possession of a trove of public domain documents from the 1800s, and I take the time to scan every one of them painstakingly and from those scans to assemble an academically useful database, for which I charge $100/person/year for access. Your contention is that because the underlying documents are public domain, you are entitled to unfettered access to my work product, despite the fact that I took steps to gate access to my work product.

The law isn't going to see it that way, I don't think. But maybe you're right. I'm not a lawyer.

Like everyone else on HN, I wish all these documents were freely available too.

Re:Aaron Swartz v. United States by brlewis on Monday July 25, 2011 @03:50PM (#2804300)
Copyright protects creative work. If you used creativity (as defined in case law) in choosing documents for your compilation, or got creative with your scanning, then you can claim exclusive rights.

Look for links in the phrase "such scans are often considered uncopyrightable" in the original article for more on this topic.

Re:Aaron Swartz v. United States by jcarreiro on Monday July 25, 2011 @03:37PM (#2804236)
> JSTOR's particular collection of documents is protected by copyright

We've discussed this on HN before. Reproductions of public domain works are not protected by copyright.

Edit: Of course a significant portion of JSTOR's archive does consist of copyrighted works.

Re:Aaron Swartz v. United States by tptacek on Monday July 25, 2011 @03:41PM (#2804254)
I thought collection copyright applied, but am happy to be wrong about that.
Re:Aaron Swartz v. United States by jcarreiro on Monday July 25, 2011 @05:13PM (#2804667)
There is a "collective works" copyright, so I guess -- I am also not a lawyer -- that if one made a copy of some database, it may be infringing on the creator's rights even if the contents of the database consisted solely of public domain works.

So I think you are correct.

Re:Aaron Swartz v. United States by lukeschlather on Tuesday July 26, 2011 @11:03AM (#2807647)
http://fairuse.stanford.edu/Copyright_and_Fair_Use_Overview/...

>You are free to copy and use individual images but copying and distributing the complete collection may infringe what is known as the “collective works” copyright. Collections of public domain material will be protected if the person who created it has used creativity in the choices and organization of the public domain material. This usually involves some unique selection process, for example, a poetry scholar compiling a book -- The Greatest Poems of e.e. cummings.

I don't think JSTOR is using what could be described as a unique selection process.