News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Texas Instruments new TI-84 Plus CE Python graphing calcu... by rtkwe on Monday August 02, 2021 @09:52AM (#28036513)
Trig functions are basically impossible to do that with unless you limit the angles drastically then you're still testing memorization instead of actual math skills.
Re:Texas Instruments new TI-84 Plus CE Python graphing calcu... by khafra on Monday August 02, 2021 @10:20AM (#28036850)
There is a common issue with limiting the angles in trig, and only requiring division with an integer or simple fraction solution: It provides a lot of help to the test-taker, based on their test-taking skills rather than their math skills.

If the test-taker can discard mistaken answers because they don't look like the kind of answer the test designer would choose, the test diverges from testing for the desired skills.

Re:Texas Instruments new TI-84 Plus CE Python graphing calcu... by rtkwe on Monday August 02, 2021 @10:54AM (#28037267)
Yeah I remember doing that too. Sometimes you could eliminate all the other answers because they weren't in the right area or the wrong sign. It was also interesting to see how answers would often have one that would be your result if you missed a step or had some other smallish error in your work.
Re:Texas Instruments new TI-84 Plus CE Python graphing calcu... by chongli on Monday August 02, 2021 @10:39AM (#28037095)
You can teach the students trig identities to expand the choice of angles. Moreover, the purpose of the lesson should be to teach the method of solving the problem. Pushing the buttons on the calculator to get a final answer in decimal form (only an approximation) is extraneous to that goal.
Re:Texas Instruments new TI-84 Plus CE Python graphing calcu... by mbreese on Monday August 02, 2021 @10:48AM (#28037199)
Or they could go really old-school and provide a look up table...

sin(x) = y

for a variety of values of x.

Or, even nicer -- instead of having a correct numerical answer, they could write the answers as formulas. Then you wouldn't need to know the actual values at all. (Then again, this could also be a pain).

But some combination of the two should be possible without needing manual computation.

Re:Texas Instruments new TI-84 Plus CE Python graphing calcu... by rtkwe on Monday August 02, 2021 @10:51AM (#28037226)
It's been a long time since I had to use the identities but looking over them quickly I don't see how they help you get the approximation of cos(70 deg) knowing the 5 basic values that I memorized back in school of (0,30,45,60,90).

Even if getting the answer needs a calculator the process to get to that point is still testing the algebraic/calculus/trig/geometry skills the test is supposed to test. You can often get rid of the need for a calculator by formulating the questions carefully so the numbers are simple to work with but sometimes you can't do that easily.

Re:Texas Instruments new TI-84 Plus CE Python graphing calcu... by chongli on Monday August 02, 2021 @03:42PM (#28041653)
Even if getting the answer needs a calculator the process to get to that point is still testing the algebraic/calculus/trig/geometry skills the test is supposed to test. You can often get rid of the need for a calculator by formulating the questions carefully so the numbers are simple to work with but sometimes you can't do that easily.

You can also just accept cos(70°) as a final answer without asking students push buttons on a calculator.

For more advanced students you could teach them to calculate even weird values like 70° using a few terms of the Maclaurin series for cosine:

cos(x) = 1 - x^2/2 + x^4/24 - x^6/720 + O(x^8)

But that's all beside the point. Mathematics education should focus on understanding and applying the concepts, not using technology. The educators' rationale that "students need to learn how to use technology" doesn't really hold water when it comes to calculators. It's far easier to teach someone with a degree in mathematics how to operate a calculator, having never used one, than it is for someone totally dependent on a calculator for even basic calculations to obtain a math degree.

Re:Texas Instruments new TI-84 Plus CE Python graphing calcu... by rtkwe on Monday August 02, 2021 @05:52PM (#28043163)
> For more advanced students you could teach them to calculate even weird values like 70° using a few terms of the Maclaurin series for cosine:

You /can/ but by the the time that is introduced, which is usually college since we're talking calculus, you don't want to test basic trigonometry. The tests at that level are about something else not about the particular values of the basic trig functions. Personally once I got to calculus very few of the questions were about the numerical result of a function.

Re:Texas Instruments new TI-84 Plus CE Python graphing calcu... by lasagnaphil on Monday August 02, 2021 @01:36PM (#28039907)
You can get close-enough ballpark answers on the angles between (0, 30, 45, 60, 90). (If the questions are multiple choice, then you can design it in a way that you don't need a calculator) And this is actually quite an important handy skill you will have in real life, since later on when you're drawing graphics/diagrams either on software or hardware you really need that intuition of ball-parking angles.