The 'good-old-boys' are generally very happy with this and love to see new people of all backgrounds take the first steps toward citizen ownership of firearms. While there may be other disagreements on a political level, those barriers seem to be forgotten when people of good will help each-other out.
I don't like messy ineffectual laws on the books.
Which is why I try not to dig too much. The more you know, the more it grates. A LexisNexus subscription is involved somewhere, I'm sure.
I'm thrilled at the spike.
That reaction is completely alien to me. There's probably more to it than "More people who aren't me have lethal weapons... fantastic!" but on a surface level, it's hard to relate to.Yes, there are those who would use your physical vulnerability against you to control you, subjugate you, and even kill you. If and when that happens, you will realize your error. Many people are trying to prevent that future from happening in the first place by being armed to fight back.
Opposing private arms ownerships doesn't necessarily equate to aiding (even accidentally) some hypothetical, future authoritarian state. It's very much not clear to me that the two are strongly connected at all, nor, if they are, that the causality runs the way proponents of the 2nd amendment as a check on authoritarian or otherwise unaccountable government assume it does.
Nope. That's about the gist of it. I hate power asymmetry. Just like I hate info asymmetry, education asymmetry, etc...
More people armed and looking out for themselves means more people coming to terms with how unfriendly the world can be when we can't take things on trust.
Looking at and contemplating a firearm, and that you may need to use it someday, making the decision to end someone else's life to save your own is one of those experiences that more than anything else in my life taught me the value of the society I was raised in, people I could trust, and the fragility of the entire thing.
You never know what you have until it isn't there, and a firearm, amongst other utility, is a stark reminder of our duty as individuals to protect, maintain, and propagate our own version of civilization. This means we have to file off the edges of ourselves and our desires for the State we live in, and accept that there are some things we shouldn't ask anyone or anything else to do for us.
I've looked into the anthropology texts, and seen the differences in pain, suffering, corruption, and abuse of power that occur based on whether a civilization structures itself around a Guardian caste, or disseminates responsibility for self preservation amongst the group as a whole. Long story short: privileged Guardian classes lead to cyclic strife as the lessons and corruptions created by the power asymmetry create a need for a reset.
I don't pretend to know all the answers, but I know weapon ownership and the contemplation of a whole new dimension of responsibility made me a better person. I can only hope it does the same for others.
Likely just a survey.
I thought the number sounded high as well until I remember that most people in my family are technically gun owners because they inherited their parents' or grandparents' firearms. In our case, our great-grandparents settled and farmed land and needed firearms. They have now been passed down as essentially the only artifacts of our lineage's settlement in this country.
They've all been stored in gun safes, which is probably why they've persisted as some of the most well-preserved family heirlooms.
Some of these guns haven't been fired for 50 or maybe even 100 years, but technically they make people "gun owners" per these surveys.
Personally I think we could use more gun control, but if I'm being completely honest I would actually be quite upset if these family heirlooms became illegal or onerous to keep due to government regulation.
There are lots of legal ways to obtain a gun legally without a background check. Many states don't require a background check between private parties. More responsible folks will ask for a voter ID (to confirm residence) and or a concealed carry permit (to confirm that person may own a firearm/not a felon), but it's not a legal requirement. Same rules may apply at a gun show. Lots and lots of guns are sold this way.
My first firearm was advertised online by a private party on a local forum, I met them in a parking lot, and paid in cash. I'd like to think I'm a responsible person, but I can certainly see how that system could wildly be abused.
Each state has different laws, you can't do that everywhere. Also there are certain federally restricted items that require a background check (normally through a ffl). Things like short barreled rifles/pistols, silencers/suppressors, full automatic, etc. Different process for manufacture vs purchase, but in theory both are tracked with serial numbers and real ID's.
It's kept on paper: https://www.thetrace.org/2016/08/atf-non-searchable-database...
In theory they are not. The individual store is supposed to keep a paper record of the sale and the background check result so that they can be audited, but that is meant to be the only record.
Of course who knows what is being done to illegally capture the data.
https://www.thetrace.org/2016/08/atf-non-searchable-database...
The NICS dataset is really bad for this sort of thing, because it's used for many purposes other than "checking eligibility to purchase gun". For example, Kentucky does a NICS check on every concealed carry permit holder every single month. Other states do the same thing, but perhaps only on a subset of permit holders or less frequently. It's my understanding that some private background check companies also use it as part of their research for job applicants and the like.
The 4473s and NICs checks are deliberately hamstrung. The ATF is not allowed to digitize these records, so they have to use paper and microfilm archives.
https://www.thetrace.org/2016/08/atf-non-searchable-database...
https://www.thetrace.org/2016/08/atf-non-searchable-database...
https://www.npr.org/2013/01/08/168889491/gun-control-advocat...
I would hang up on that call and I don't even own a gun. Surely some people will answer, but wide swaths of the American public, gun owning or otherwise, would refuse to answer these sort of questions on basic principle and/or common sense. If you could get an estimate for what portion of gun owners relative to non-owners would refuse to answer those questions then you might have something for the statisticians to work with, but I don't see how you could estimate even that.
Surveys give you data, but sometimes that data is worth less than dirt.
Do you own any firearms?
Do you use illegal drugs?
Have you ever had an abortion?
How do you not expect a substantial portion of your respondents to either refuse to answer or simply lie when you ask questions like that?
Surveyers do expect it. And any errors are measurable and have been studied:
> Polling potential or existing consumers is often the first step when it comes time for new businesses to enter the market or existing ones to add new products. And in today’s tele-connected world, no longer do researchers have to rely on focus groups, in-depth interviews or direct mail surveys to get the job done. Instead, a host of remotely accessible options exist that enables savvy market researchers the choice of connecting to the market without physically having to mobilize it. One of the oldest and most staid of all the research methods is the ubiquitous phone survey. It’s a no frills, “tried and true” alternative for companies looking for robust information quickly. But it does have its limitations. Take a look at the phone survey’s advantages and disadvantages:
* https://www.cfrinc.net/cfrblog/phone-surveys-data-collection
Also: "A comparison of reliability between telephone and web-based surveys"
* http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2007.02.015
There's a whole plethora of papers on the reliability (or lack thereof) of various surveying methods, including over the phone.
This doesn't say anything about the likelihood of people lying when a stranger calls them up and asks questions about a controversial/sensitive topic.
> http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2007.02.015
This paper compares the (claimed) reliability of web surveys with the (claimed) reliability of phone surveys. The paper is behind a paywall, but at least in the abstract, it does not appear to directly address the likelihood of people lying when a stranger calls them up and asks questions about a controversial/sensitive topic.
> There's a whole plethora of papers on the reliability (or lack thereof) of various surveying methods, including over the phone.
That may be true, but you don't appear to have cited any of them. Care to try again?
* https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/215824401247234...
The general point is that surveyors know people aren't always completely honest when asked questions.
Most human beings in general are aware that other humans will lie to them at times when asked questions, so why should surveyors being any different? Whereas people use 'heuristics' to judge another's honesty, surveyors will use quantitate methods.
This paper talks about figuring out how to tell when dishonest people are taking the same survey more than once. Also, it's discussing people who voluntarily take internet surveys repeatedly to attempt to cook the numbers, not people who are involuntarily cold-called at an identifiable telephone number, and wish to avoid answering a sensitive question.
Again, not even close to what you're claiming. That's the third non-relevant citation you've put forward. I think we're done here.
> The general point is that surveyors know people aren't always completely honest when asked questions.
Of course they know that. They just don't talk about it.
And no, there's no "quantitate method" to tell how many people are lying, barring an external verification source independent of the survey.
Tell me the approximate percentage of people who will lie when a stranger calls them up and asks them how many firearms they own, then tell me how much money you'd be willing to bet on that being the correct number.
I'd like to know the methodology that leads to that conclusion. Unless they are making some seriously handwavey assumptions in the absence of a 1:1 binding of individual/household to gun purchase which is technically illegal for the Government to maintain.
(Though not really because it's likely a third-party that is doing the aggregation that the government would never think of peeping a look at I'm sure.)
Although, I'd still like to know how "required FBI background check", which I bet all are tracked and cross-referencable with the requestor, thereby giving a synthetic key to "gun purchase" does not translate to database of potential gun owners.
Really wish these types of thoughts would stop occurring to me, I only have so much room for research projects in my head. >_<