News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anonymous advice: What’s good career advice you wouldn’t ... by SamvitJ on Friday July 30, 2021 @10:39PM (#28014738)
I'm less inclined to take this advice (though much of it is fine) because there is no name attached to it. Why would I take an unknown person's advice on something? How do I know I can trust them if I don't know anything about their career?

Even more importantly, I don't know the context behind any of this advice, which is needed to process it appropriately.

Some examples:

> If you need a PhD, get through it ASAP.

Is this really good advice? I would encourage people to be extremely skeptical about getting PhDs - i.e., work in the real world first - and then if you still really want to do one, do it well, so that you have a shot at the kind of post-PhD opportunities that would make it worth it.

> Develop specific skills and think about specialising early.

The anecdote on this is weird and I'm not sure I agree (depends on what they mean by "specialize"). If by specialize, they mean "major in something practical" sure I agree with that. If by specialize, they mean, "aim to become a expert in some niche in your field in college", disagree.

> Be wary of slow feedback loops.

Agree mostly, but disagree with the specific examples given. If you know you want to be a lawyer, go to law school.

> Be strategic in your career decisions.

Agree, but the opposite advice would also be fine: careers are long and complex, so don't attempt to be overly strategic early on.

> Think about going to a startup.

This just looks like startup shilling.

> When you’re great at your job, no one’s advice is that useful.

Not sure this is true.

> Know the relevant senior people.

Not sure this is THAT important early on in your career.

> Be irrationally optimistic.

Useful if you are in sales or a founder, but for most other careers (e.g., engineering), I would advise rational optimism.

Re:Anonymous advice: What’s good career advice you wouldn’t ... by SamvitJ on Saturday July 31, 2021 @10:46PM (#28023396)
Could someone explain why this is being downvoted? I didn't mean it in a snarky way, I just am not able to place some of this advice without knowing who it is from!
Re:Anonymous advice: What’s good career advice you wouldn’t ... by gamechangr on Monday August 02, 2021 @06:14PM (#28043369)
I didnt down vote you, but your asking to become more self aware ( Could someone explain why...)

I think you lost your reader on your first sentence. Maybe don't read an article called " Anonymous advice" and lead with "...less inclined..why would I take...anonymous advice'.

hope that helps

Re:Anonymous advice: What’s good career advice you wouldn’t ... by SamvitJ on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:23PM (#28069469)
Ah got it, I actually appreciate that clarification! That makes sense. I guess the article didn't convince me that anonymous advice can work.